Earliest recorded position in this interval.
Rank— → #136National score— → —
World Wealthiest Country · Abundance history
Brazil 🇧🇷 · Country History
Movement in the World Wealthiest Country Abundance Scorecard, measured through access to life rather than GDP or money. Every archived point adjustment and source remains available; unchanged observations are condensed by date, not deleted.
World Wealthiest Country · Recorded rank history
52 meaningful rank/score point(s)Dated changes with readable spacing · diagonal lines show rank movement · horizontal lines show held positions · scroll left for earlier dates.
National score over the same dates
The rank can hold while points move. This chart shows only actually recorded score readings; its vertical scale follows the visible minimum and maximum.
Dots mark initial readings and rank or score changes; unchanged readings extend a dated interval. Select a dot for the score and related archived events.
Selected rank observation
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #55 to #136 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#55 → #136National score— → —
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#136 → #139National score— → —
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #136 to #139 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#136 → #139National score— → —
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#139 → #140National score— → —
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #139 to #140 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#139 → #140National score— → —
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
National score changed while rank held.
Rank#140 → #140National score— → -63.21
Held through 9 Oct 2026 · 07:51 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#140 → #148National score-63.21 → -64.46
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #140 to #148 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#140 → #148National score— → —
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#148 → #147National score-64.46 → -64.46
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 10 Oct 2026 · 15:02 GMT-0500; 1 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #148 to #147 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#148 → #147National score-64.46 → -64.46
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Puerto Rico #147 → #158; -64.37 → -65.67 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#147 → #112National score-64.46 → -64.46
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from pending to 20.25. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | — | 20.25 |
| Base category score | — | 20.25 |
| Research coverage (%) | — | 86.00 |
| Category weight (%) | — | 6.00 |
| Positive Contribution (25%) | — | 65.00 |
| Mutuality / Local Benefit (25%) | — | 50.00 |
| Documented Harm / Extraction (35%) | — | -35.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | — | 25.00 |
Updated reasoning: Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents South-South institutional capacity building, including Brazil–Haiti health services, rehabilitation, water and training, with partner participation. Deforestation and commodity-related ecological impacts create real cross-border concerns, and independently verified long-run mutuality is incomplete. Scoring values are a TBF normative assessment of the cited evidence, not a claim that assistance quantity equals verified benefit.
Sources archived after the change (1)
Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents about 15 bilateral projects since 2004 involving health systems, rehabilitation, water-catchment cisterns, farming, and local technical training; completed outputs support positive contribution but do not by themselves quantify all long-run local outcomes.
Water & Sanitation Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Water & Sanitation Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 17.00 | 17.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: A water-rich country still has a material gap between physical water endowment and safely managed household water, sanitation and wastewater treatment.
Sources archived before (3)
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Safely managed drinking water. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 30.75 | 30.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil possesses extraordinary natural and cultural beauty and positive life-evaluation evidence. Everyday Delight Reach still needs deeper national and municipal evidence.
Sources archived before (2)
World Happiness Report position: 32.00000000
Average life evaluation: 6.63400000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average life evaluation. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
World Happiness Report position: 32.00000000
Average life evaluation: 6.63400000
Mobility & Reachability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Mobility & Reachability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 13.00 | 13.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has extensive movement infrastructure, but commuting burden, road mortality and unequal spatial access reduce the amount of mobility that returns usable time.
Sources archived before (2)
Road traffic mortality rate: 15.70000000
People travelling to work: 71.20000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: People travelling to work. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Road traffic mortality rate: 15.70000000
People travelling to work: 71.20000000
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 29.75 | 29.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil begins with exceptional biological abundance. Recent deforestation direction improved, while substantial absolute living-ground loss remains.
Sources archived before (3)
Deforestation detected: 984794.00000000
Forest area: 59.00000000
Brazilian agricultural publication examined the family’s Foodway, productive diversity, soil cover, public food and resilience thinking.
Sources archived after the change (4)
INPE consolidated the 2025 Amazon Legal deforestation rate at 5,731 km², 12.07% lower than 2024; the earlier October 2025 estimate was 5,796 km². The previously published 2025 Cerrado estimate was 7,235 km². These remain sizeable habitat losses despite improvement.
Deforestation detected: 984794.00000000
Forest area: 59.00000000
Brazilian agricultural publication examined the family’s Foodway, productive diversity, soil cover, public food and resilience thinking.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 22.25 | 22.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has extraordinary land capacity. TBF distinguishes that from ordinary families having practical access to productive land and services outside major commercial centres.
Sources archived before (3)
Agricultural establishment area held by establishments ≥1,000 ha: 47.60000000
Population living in urban areas: 88.00000000
Land area: 8.36000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Incra confirms settlement plots are allocated to selected rural families without means to purchase land; a selection process, registration and settlement-specific rules apply, so this is an actual conditional route, not universal open land access.
Agricultural establishment area held by establishments ≥1,000 ha: 47.60000000
Population living in urban areas: 88.00000000
Land area: 8.36000000
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -4.50 | -4.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Lethal violence has improved but remains a major source of human friction. Public safety and dependable justice are essential abundance conditions.
Sources archived before (3)
World Justice Project position: 78.00000000
Recorded homicides: 42590.00000000
Homicide rate: 20.10000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Atlas da Violencia 2026 reports 42,590 homicides in 2024, 20.1 per 100,000 (-7.4% from 2023); this improves direction but remains a major public-safety burden.
World Justice Project position: 78.00000000
Recorded homicides: 42590.00000000
Homicide rate: 20.10000000
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 70.25 | 70.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil combines broad visitor access with unusually practical migrant-life pathways: CPF access, bank-account possibility, temporary use of foreign driving licences, MERCOSUR residence, frontier regularisation and humanitarian residence routes. Visa requirements and financial-institution discretion keep the score below deep-abundance levels.
Sources archived before (6)
Brazil maintains specific residence pathways for neighbouring nationals and humanitarian situations including Haiti, Syria, Afghanistan and Ukraine
Nationals of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay may obtain temporary residence; eligible temporary residence can become indefinite after two years
Foreign driving licence usability: 180.00000000
Non-residents may open real-denominated accounts at institutions authorised for foreign exchange; institutions retain onboarding discretion
Foreign residents and non-residents may apply for CPF; registration is free through Receita channels
Broad visa-free list; eVisa available to Australia, Canada and United States
Sources archived after the change (7)
Brazil requires nationals of Australia, Canada and the US to obtain an eVisa for tourism/business from 10 April 2025. This is an online visa rather than visa-free access and does not imply eligibility for all foreign nationals.
Brazil maintains specific residence pathways for neighbouring nationals and humanitarian situations including Haiti, Syria, Afghanistan and Ukraine
Nationals of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay may obtain temporary residence; eligible temporary residence can become indefinite after two years
Foreign driving licence usability: 180.00000000
Non-residents may open real-denominated accounts at institutions authorised for foreign exchange; institutions retain onboarding discretion
Foreign residents and non-residents may apply for CPF; registration is free through Receita channels
Broad visa-free list; eVisa available to Australia, Canada and United States
Human Time & Burden Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 14.00 | 14.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil does not show an extreme national long-hours profile, but informality, commuting and labour underutilisation mean productivity does not return equally as secure family time.
Sources archived before (3)
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 2.50 | 2.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Extensive housing capacity coexists with vacant dwellings, a large housing deficit and people living in street situations. Stock alone therefore does not establish shelter abundance.
Sources archived before (3)
People registered in street situation: 327925.00000000
Estimated housing deficit: 6.22000000
Vacant private dwellings: 11.40000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Vacant private dwellings. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
People registered in street situation: 327925.00000000
Estimated housing deficit: 6.22000000
Vacant private dwellings: 11.40000000
Health & Care Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Health & Care Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 38.80 | 38.80 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has substantial public-health capacity and strong service coverage, while maternal and child outcomes show remaining gaps between capability and lived health.
Sources archived before (3)
Under-five mortality rate: 14.59000000
Maternal mortality ratio: 66.90000000
Universal health coverage service index: 84.00000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Brazil Health Ministry states that SUS guarantees universal comprehensive free healthcare from prevention and primary care to complex hospital treatment; geographic queues and service performance must be evaluated separately.
Under-five mortality rate: 14.59000000
Maternal mortality ratio: 66.90000000
Universal health coverage service index: 84.00000000
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 25.30 | 25.30 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has formidable food capacity and household food security improved in 2024, but nourishment still does not reach every household. Free Food Reach remains a TBF-native research layer.
Sources archived before (3)
Households with severe food insecurity: 3.20000000
Households with any food insecurity: 24.20000000
Food-secure households: 75.80000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
IBGE-based 2024 food-security reporting shows 75.8% of households food secure and 3.2% in severe insecurity; universal school meals reach students, not free everyday food for all households.
Households with severe food insecurity: 3.20000000
Households with any food insecurity: 24.20000000
Food-secure households: 75.80000000
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -49.00 | -49.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil continues to form large numbers of families, while fertility is below replacement, couple-with-children family forms have declined and parental-time supports remain uneven.
Sources archived before (5)
Families consisting of couples with children: 42.00000000
Total fertility rate: 1.55000000
Registered divorces: 428301.00000000
Registered marriages: 948925.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Sources archived after the change (6)
IBGE 2022 Census published 2025 records a total fertility rate of 1.55 children per woman, substantially below replacement and the authored 5.0 target; this is an observed demographic measure, not proof of cause.
Families consisting of couples with children: 42.00000000
Total fertility rate: 1.55000000
Registered divorces: 428301.00000000
Registered marriages: 948925.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Energy & Household Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Energy & Household Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 64.05 | 64.05 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Near-universal electricity and high clean-cooking access show a strong example of infrastructure capability reaching household life.
Sources archived before (2)
Access to clean cooking fuels and technologies: 96.50000000
Access to electricity: 99.80000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
The Luz do Povo social electricity tariff provides an allowance of up to 80 kWh monthly with no consumption charge to eligible CadUnico and other qualifying households; above-threshold consumption and other charges may still apply.
Access to clean cooking fuels and technologies: 96.50000000
Access to electricity: 99.80000000
Education & Human Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Education & Human Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 21.80 | 21.80 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: School participation is very high, but foundational learning and practical civilization capability remain distinct from attendance.
Sources archived before (4)
Learning poverty estimate: 47.00000000
Adult illiteracy age 15+: 4.90000000
School attendance ages 6–14: 99.50000000
Brazilian publication carried the family’s proposal to connect local digital capability, youth training, tourism and biodiversity documentation in Prado.
Sources archived after the change (5)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: School attendance ages 6–14. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Learning poverty estimate: 47.00000000
Adult illiteracy age 15+: 4.90000000
School attendance ages 6–14: 99.50000000
Brazilian publication carried the family’s proposal to connect local digital capability, youth training, tourism and biodiversity documentation in Prado.
Durability, Repair & Material Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Durability, Repair & Material Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -14.50 | -14.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Waste collection capacity is high, but environmentally adequate final disposal and broader material-return systems remain far from a deeply circular civilization.
Sources archived before (2)
Environmentally adequate final disposal: 59.70000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 81.60000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Municipal solid waste generated. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Environmentally adequate final disposal: 59.70000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 81.60000000
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate) changed from 3.18 to 6.5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate)
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 3.18 | 6.50 |
| Food / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Housing / Land / 4 | — | 1.00 |
| Healthcare / 4 | — | 3.50 |
| Transportation / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Water / Energy / 4 | — | 1.00 |
Category point adjustment: +3.32 category points
Earlier reasoning: Transitional proxy or benchmark; no invented five-part direct audit.
Updated reasoning: {"food":"PNAE provides school food nationwide to public basic-education students; ordinary household food remains payment-gated. School food earns the TBF 0.5\/4 allowance.","housing_land":"Incra agrarian-reform settlements provide an actual conditional path to productive rural plots for selected eligible families. MCMV subsidized housing still usually requires financing or household contribution.","healthcare":"SUS provides nationwide universal public healthcare without direct patient fees, including primary and specialist services. Queues, coverage unevenness and gaps in access keep this below 4\/4.","transportation":"Fare-free or discounted interstate journeys for specific eligible groups exist; nationwide ordinary urban\/regional travel is not fare-free.","water_energy":"Luz do Povo guarantees no electricity consumption charge on up to 80kWh a month for qualifying low-income households; this is means-tested and household water remains generally charged."}
Sources archived after the change (6)
The headline TBF Abundance Score changed after the underlying published country dataset changed.
TBF points-64.46 → -60.50
Earlier score events did not preserve an exact category-by-category diff. Review detailed category change events recorded after the new history audit was activated.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #147 to #112 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#147 → #112National score-64.46 → -60.50
Countries that fell below this country (35)
- Sri Lanka #112 → #113; -60.54 → -60.54 points
- Belize #113 → #114; -60.77 → -60.77 points
- Algeria #114 → #115; -60.96 → -60.96 points
- Suriname #115 → #116; -61.00 → -61.00 points
- British Virgin Islands #116 → #117; -61.03 → -61.03 points
- Moldova #117 → #118; -61.09 → -61.09 points
- Finland #118 → #119; -61.29 → -61.29 points
- Panama #119 → #120; -61.39 → -61.39 points
- Bolivia #120 → #121; -61.43 → -61.43 points
- Poland #121 → #122; -61.60 → -61.60 points
- India #122 → #123; -61.80 → -61.80 points
- Sint Maarten #123 → #124; -61.82 → -61.82 points
- Paraguay #124 → #125; -61.88 → -61.88 points
- Tunisia #125 → #126; -61.97 → -61.97 points
- Cabo Verde #126 → #127; -62.15 → -62.15 points
- Saint Vincent and the Grenadines #127 → #128; -62.25 → -62.25 points
- Botswana #128 → #129; -62.29 → -62.29 points
- Czech Republic #129 → #130; -62.35 → -62.35 points
- Indonesia #130 → #131; -62.47 → -62.47 points
- Qatar #131 → #132; -62.59 → -62.59 points
- Peru #132 → #133; -62.69 → -62.69 points
- Croatia #133 → #134; -62.75 → -62.75 points
- Belarus #134 → #135; -62.78 → -62.78 points
- Saint Kitts and Nevis #135 → #136; -62.90 → -62.90 points
- Rwanda #136 → #137; -63.07 → -63.07 points
- Philippines #137 → #138; -63.27 → -63.27 points
- Mayotte #138 → #139; -63.38 → -63.38 points
- Estonia #139 → #140; -63.52 → -63.52 points
- Mexico #140 → #141; -63.85 → -63.85 points
- Jordan #141 → #142; -63.98 → -63.98 points
- Namibia #142 → #143; -64.10 → -64.10 points
- Mongolia #143 → #144; -64.11 → -64.11 points
- Cambodia #144 → #145; -64.15 → -64.15 points
- Kyrgyzstan #145 → #146; -64.17 → -64.17 points
- Ecuador #146 → #147; -64.30 → -64.30 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #147 to #112 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#147 → #112National score-64.46 → -64.46
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (35)
- Sri Lanka #112 → #113; -60.54 → -60.54 points
- Belize #113 → #114; -60.77 → -60.77 points
- Algeria #114 → #115; -60.96 → -60.96 points
- Suriname #115 → #116; -61.00 → -61.00 points
- British Virgin Islands #116 → #117; -61.03 → -61.03 points
- Moldova #117 → #118; -61.09 → -61.09 points
- Finland #118 → #119; -61.29 → -61.29 points
- Panama #119 → #120; -61.39 → -61.39 points
- Bolivia #120 → #121; -61.43 → -61.43 points
- Poland #121 → #122; -61.60 → -61.60 points
- India #122 → #123; -61.80 → -61.80 points
- Sint Maarten #123 → #124; -61.82 → -61.82 points
- Paraguay #124 → #125; -61.88 → -61.88 points
- Tunisia #125 → #126; -61.97 → -61.97 points
- Cabo Verde #126 → #127; -62.15 → -62.15 points
- Saint Vincent and the Grenadines #127 → #128; -62.25 → -62.25 points
- Botswana #128 → #129; -62.29 → -62.29 points
- Czech Republic #129 → #130; -62.35 → -62.35 points
- Indonesia #130 → #131; -62.47 → -62.47 points
- Qatar #131 → #132; -62.59 → -62.59 points
- Peru #132 → #133; -62.69 → -62.69 points
- Croatia #133 → #134; -62.75 → -62.75 points
- Belarus #134 → #135; -62.78 → -62.78 points
- Saint Kitts and Nevis #135 → #136; -62.90 → -62.90 points
- Rwanda #136 → #137; -63.07 → -63.07 points
- Philippines #137 → #138; -63.27 → -63.27 points
- Mayotte #138 → #139; -63.38 → -63.38 points
- Estonia #139 → #140; -63.52 → -63.52 points
- Mexico #140 → #141; -63.85 → -63.85 points
- Jordan #141 → #142; -63.98 → -63.98 points
- Namibia #142 → #143; -64.10 → -64.10 points
- Mongolia #143 → #144; -64.11 → -64.11 points
- Cambodia #144 → #145; -64.15 → -64.15 points
- Kyrgyzstan #145 → #146; -64.17 → -64.17 points
- Ecuador #146 → #147; -64.30 → -64.30 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
National score changed while rank held.
Rank#112 → #112National score-64.46 → -60.50
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from pending to 20.25. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | — | 20.25 |
| Base category score | — | 20.25 |
| Research coverage (%) | — | 86.00 |
| Category weight (%) | — | 6.00 |
| Positive Contribution (25%) | — | 65.00 |
| Mutuality / Local Benefit (25%) | — | 50.00 |
| Documented Harm / Extraction (35%) | — | -35.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | — | 25.00 |
Updated reasoning: Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents South-South institutional capacity building, including Brazil–Haiti health services, rehabilitation, water and training, with partner participation. Deforestation and commodity-related ecological impacts create real cross-border concerns, and independently verified long-run mutuality is incomplete. Scoring values are a TBF normative assessment of the cited evidence, not a claim that assistance quantity equals verified benefit.
Sources archived after the change (1)
Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents about 15 bilateral projects since 2004 involving health systems, rehabilitation, water-catchment cisterns, farming, and local technical training; completed outputs support positive contribution but do not by themselves quantify all long-run local outcomes.
Water & Sanitation Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Water & Sanitation Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 17.00 | 17.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: A water-rich country still has a material gap between physical water endowment and safely managed household water, sanitation and wastewater treatment.
Sources archived before (3)
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Safely managed drinking water. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 30.75 | 30.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil possesses extraordinary natural and cultural beauty and positive life-evaluation evidence. Everyday Delight Reach still needs deeper national and municipal evidence.
Sources archived before (2)
World Happiness Report position: 32.00000000
Average life evaluation: 6.63400000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average life evaluation. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
World Happiness Report position: 32.00000000
Average life evaluation: 6.63400000
Mobility & Reachability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Mobility & Reachability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 13.00 | 13.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has extensive movement infrastructure, but commuting burden, road mortality and unequal spatial access reduce the amount of mobility that returns usable time.
Sources archived before (2)
Road traffic mortality rate: 15.70000000
People travelling to work: 71.20000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: People travelling to work. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Road traffic mortality rate: 15.70000000
People travelling to work: 71.20000000
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 29.75 | 29.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil begins with exceptional biological abundance. Recent deforestation direction improved, while substantial absolute living-ground loss remains.
Sources archived before (3)
Deforestation detected: 984794.00000000
Forest area: 59.00000000
Brazilian agricultural publication examined the family’s Foodway, productive diversity, soil cover, public food and resilience thinking.
Sources archived after the change (4)
INPE consolidated the 2025 Amazon Legal deforestation rate at 5,731 km², 12.07% lower than 2024; the earlier October 2025 estimate was 5,796 km². The previously published 2025 Cerrado estimate was 7,235 km². These remain sizeable habitat losses despite improvement.
Deforestation detected: 984794.00000000
Forest area: 59.00000000
Brazilian agricultural publication examined the family’s Foodway, productive diversity, soil cover, public food and resilience thinking.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 22.25 | 22.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has extraordinary land capacity. TBF distinguishes that from ordinary families having practical access to productive land and services outside major commercial centres.
Sources archived before (3)
Agricultural establishment area held by establishments ≥1,000 ha: 47.60000000
Population living in urban areas: 88.00000000
Land area: 8.36000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Incra confirms settlement plots are allocated to selected rural families without means to purchase land; a selection process, registration and settlement-specific rules apply, so this is an actual conditional route, not universal open land access.
Agricultural establishment area held by establishments ≥1,000 ha: 47.60000000
Population living in urban areas: 88.00000000
Land area: 8.36000000
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -4.50 | -4.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Lethal violence has improved but remains a major source of human friction. Public safety and dependable justice are essential abundance conditions.
Sources archived before (3)
World Justice Project position: 78.00000000
Recorded homicides: 42590.00000000
Homicide rate: 20.10000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Atlas da Violencia 2026 reports 42,590 homicides in 2024, 20.1 per 100,000 (-7.4% from 2023); this improves direction but remains a major public-safety burden.
World Justice Project position: 78.00000000
Recorded homicides: 42590.00000000
Homicide rate: 20.10000000
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 70.25 | 70.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil combines broad visitor access with unusually practical migrant-life pathways: CPF access, bank-account possibility, temporary use of foreign driving licences, MERCOSUR residence, frontier regularisation and humanitarian residence routes. Visa requirements and financial-institution discretion keep the score below deep-abundance levels.
Sources archived before (6)
Brazil maintains specific residence pathways for neighbouring nationals and humanitarian situations including Haiti, Syria, Afghanistan and Ukraine
Nationals of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay may obtain temporary residence; eligible temporary residence can become indefinite after two years
Foreign driving licence usability: 180.00000000
Non-residents may open real-denominated accounts at institutions authorised for foreign exchange; institutions retain onboarding discretion
Foreign residents and non-residents may apply for CPF; registration is free through Receita channels
Broad visa-free list; eVisa available to Australia, Canada and United States
Sources archived after the change (7)
Brazil requires nationals of Australia, Canada and the US to obtain an eVisa for tourism/business from 10 April 2025. This is an online visa rather than visa-free access and does not imply eligibility for all foreign nationals.
Brazil maintains specific residence pathways for neighbouring nationals and humanitarian situations including Haiti, Syria, Afghanistan and Ukraine
Nationals of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay may obtain temporary residence; eligible temporary residence can become indefinite after two years
Foreign driving licence usability: 180.00000000
Non-residents may open real-denominated accounts at institutions authorised for foreign exchange; institutions retain onboarding discretion
Foreign residents and non-residents may apply for CPF; registration is free through Receita channels
Broad visa-free list; eVisa available to Australia, Canada and United States
Human Time & Burden Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 14.00 | 14.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil does not show an extreme national long-hours profile, but informality, commuting and labour underutilisation mean productivity does not return equally as secure family time.
Sources archived before (3)
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 2.50 | 2.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Extensive housing capacity coexists with vacant dwellings, a large housing deficit and people living in street situations. Stock alone therefore does not establish shelter abundance.
Sources archived before (3)
People registered in street situation: 327925.00000000
Estimated housing deficit: 6.22000000
Vacant private dwellings: 11.40000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Vacant private dwellings. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
People registered in street situation: 327925.00000000
Estimated housing deficit: 6.22000000
Vacant private dwellings: 11.40000000
Health & Care Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Health & Care Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 38.80 | 38.80 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has substantial public-health capacity and strong service coverage, while maternal and child outcomes show remaining gaps between capability and lived health.
Sources archived before (3)
Under-five mortality rate: 14.59000000
Maternal mortality ratio: 66.90000000
Universal health coverage service index: 84.00000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Brazil Health Ministry states that SUS guarantees universal comprehensive free healthcare from prevention and primary care to complex hospital treatment; geographic queues and service performance must be evaluated separately.
Under-five mortality rate: 14.59000000
Maternal mortality ratio: 66.90000000
Universal health coverage service index: 84.00000000
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 25.30 | 25.30 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has formidable food capacity and household food security improved in 2024, but nourishment still does not reach every household. Free Food Reach remains a TBF-native research layer.
Sources archived before (3)
Households with severe food insecurity: 3.20000000
Households with any food insecurity: 24.20000000
Food-secure households: 75.80000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
IBGE-based 2024 food-security reporting shows 75.8% of households food secure and 3.2% in severe insecurity; universal school meals reach students, not free everyday food for all households.
Households with severe food insecurity: 3.20000000
Households with any food insecurity: 24.20000000
Food-secure households: 75.80000000
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -49.00 | -49.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil continues to form large numbers of families, while fertility is below replacement, couple-with-children family forms have declined and parental-time supports remain uneven.
Sources archived before (5)
Families consisting of couples with children: 42.00000000
Total fertility rate: 1.55000000
Registered divorces: 428301.00000000
Registered marriages: 948925.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Sources archived after the change (6)
IBGE 2022 Census published 2025 records a total fertility rate of 1.55 children per woman, substantially below replacement and the authored 5.0 target; this is an observed demographic measure, not proof of cause.
Families consisting of couples with children: 42.00000000
Total fertility rate: 1.55000000
Registered divorces: 428301.00000000
Registered marriages: 948925.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Energy & Household Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Energy & Household Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 64.05 | 64.05 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Near-universal electricity and high clean-cooking access show a strong example of infrastructure capability reaching household life.
Sources archived before (2)
Access to clean cooking fuels and technologies: 96.50000000
Access to electricity: 99.80000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
The Luz do Povo social electricity tariff provides an allowance of up to 80 kWh monthly with no consumption charge to eligible CadUnico and other qualifying households; above-threshold consumption and other charges may still apply.
Access to clean cooking fuels and technologies: 96.50000000
Access to electricity: 99.80000000
Education & Human Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Education & Human Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 21.80 | 21.80 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: School participation is very high, but foundational learning and practical civilization capability remain distinct from attendance.
Sources archived before (4)
Learning poverty estimate: 47.00000000
Adult illiteracy age 15+: 4.90000000
School attendance ages 6–14: 99.50000000
Brazilian publication carried the family’s proposal to connect local digital capability, youth training, tourism and biodiversity documentation in Prado.
Sources archived after the change (5)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: School attendance ages 6–14. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Learning poverty estimate: 47.00000000
Adult illiteracy age 15+: 4.90000000
School attendance ages 6–14: 99.50000000
Brazilian publication carried the family’s proposal to connect local digital capability, youth training, tourism and biodiversity documentation in Prado.
Durability, Repair & Material Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Durability, Repair & Material Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -14.50 | -14.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Waste collection capacity is high, but environmentally adequate final disposal and broader material-return systems remain far from a deeply circular civilization.
Sources archived before (2)
Environmentally adequate final disposal: 59.70000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 81.60000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Municipal solid waste generated. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Environmentally adequate final disposal: 59.70000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 81.60000000
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate) changed from 3.18 to 6.5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate)
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 3.18 | 6.50 |
| Food / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Housing / Land / 4 | — | 1.00 |
| Healthcare / 4 | — | 3.50 |
| Transportation / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Water / Energy / 4 | — | 1.00 |
Category point adjustment: +3.32 category points
Earlier reasoning: Transitional proxy or benchmark; no invented five-part direct audit.
Updated reasoning: {"food":"PNAE provides school food nationwide to public basic-education students; ordinary household food remains payment-gated. School food earns the TBF 0.5\/4 allowance.","housing_land":"Incra agrarian-reform settlements provide an actual conditional path to productive rural plots for selected eligible families. MCMV subsidized housing still usually requires financing or household contribution.","healthcare":"SUS provides nationwide universal public healthcare without direct patient fees, including primary and specialist services. Queues, coverage unevenness and gaps in access keep this below 4\/4.","transportation":"Fare-free or discounted interstate journeys for specific eligible groups exist; nationwide ordinary urban\/regional travel is not fare-free.","water_energy":"Luz do Povo guarantees no electricity consumption charge on up to 80kWh a month for qualifying low-income households; this is means-tested and household water remains generally charged."}
Sources archived after the change (6)
The headline TBF Abundance Score changed after the underlying published country dataset changed.
TBF points-64.46 → -60.50
Earlier score events did not preserve an exact category-by-category diff. Review detailed category change events recorded after the new history audit was activated.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#112 → #111National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #112 to #111 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#112 → #111National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- China #93 → #129; -59.17 → -62.31 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#111 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 02:50 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #111 to #110 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#111 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Germany #103 → #112; -59.98 → -60.57 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#110 → #111National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 02:50 GMT-0500; 7 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #110 to #111 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#110 → #111National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that moved ahead of this country (1)
- India #122 → #104; -61.80 → -59.89 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#111 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 02:50 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #111 to #110 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#111 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Türkiye #102 → #117; -59.72 → -59.72 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#110 → #109National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 02:50 GMT-0500; 6 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #110 to #109 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#110 → #109National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Taiwan #94 → #126; -59.23 → -59.23 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#109 → #108National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 12:02 GMT-0500; 11 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#108 → #107National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 12:02 GMT-0500; 12 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #108 to #107 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#108 → #107National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Kazakhstan #92 → #133; -58.99 → -58.99 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#107 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.98
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 12:02 GMT-0500; 22 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
Human Time & Burden Return changed from 14 to 5.25. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 14.00 | 5.25 |
| Base category score | 14.00 | 5.25 |
| Research coverage (%) | 95.00 | 90.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -25.00 | -45.00 |
| Return / Regeneration (15%) | 25.00 | 0.00 |
Category point adjustment: -8.75 category points
Earlier reasoning: Brazil does not show an extreme national long-hours profile, but informality, commuting and labour underutilisation mean productivity does not return equally as secure family time.
Updated reasoning: Family Time 3.1, 25/35/25/15. IBGE documented 37.8% informal work and 25.2% self-employment in Q2 2025; insecure schedules reduce reliable household time, though extra-job prevalence is not established. The two newly evaluated rails reflect time used for paid and unpaid work, and real time left at home. Source https://agenciadenoticias.ibge.gov.br/agencia-sala-de-imprensa/2013-agencia-de-noticias/releases/44244-pnad-continua-trimestral-desocupacao-cai-em-18-das-27-ufs-no-segundo-trimestre-de-2025
Sources archived before (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
IBGE documented 37.8% informal work and 25.2% self-employment in Q2 2025; insecure schedules reduce reliable household time, though extra-job prevalence is not established. Authored TBF rail judgment, not government score. All paid jobs and unpaid home burden considered; friction -45, time returned +0.
IBGE documented 37.8% informal work and 25.2% self-employment in Q2 2025; insecure schedules reduce reliable household time, though extra-job prevalence is not established. Authored TBF rail judgment, not government score. All paid jobs and unpaid home burden considered; friction -45, time returned +0.
IBGE PNAD Contínua Q2 2025 records informal employment at 37.8% and self-employment at 25.2%. These are employment conditions, not a measured multiple-jobholder rate.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from 20.25 to 25.5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 20.25 | 25.50 |
| Base category score | 20.25 | 25.50 |
| Research coverage (%) | 86.00 | 90.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | 25.00 | 12.50 |
Category point adjustment: +5.25 category points
Earlier reasoning: Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents South-South institutional capacity building, including Brazil–Haiti health services, rehabilitation, water and training, with partner participation. Deforestation and commodity-related ecological impacts create real cross-border concerns, and independently verified long-run mutuality is incomplete. Scoring values are a TBF normative assessment of the cited evidence, not a claim that assistance quantity equals verified benefit.
Updated reasoning: Footprint 3.1 weights 25/25/20/30. Export +20 (15%), import +5 (15%). 8.99 million kg of plastic scrap exported, far below the biggest exporters reviewed; recorded transport still carries handling work. A US$3.31m plastic scrap import stream is documented; risk judgment moderated by smaller available trade observations. BASEL reference https://www.basel.int/Default.aspx?tabid=8427
Sources archived before (1)
Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents about 15 bilateral projects since 2004 involving health systems, rehabilitation, water-catchment cisterns, farming, and local technical training; completed outputs support positive contribution but do not by themselves quantify all long-run local outcomes.
Sources archived after the change (11)
A US$3.31m plastic scrap import stream is documented; risk judgment moderated by smaller available trade observations. The score measures a documented material-transfer pressure and policy response under TBF standards, not verified toxic exposure.
8.99 million kg of plastic scrap exported, far below the biggest exporters reviewed; recorded transport still carries handling work. The score measures a documented material-transfer pressure and policy response under TBF standards, not verified toxic exposure.
Export role +20 and import role +5. 8.99 million kg of plastic scrap exported, far below the biggest exporters reviewed; recorded transport still carries handling work. A US$3.31m plastic scrap import stream is documented; risk judgment moderated by smaller available trade observations. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Export role +20 and import role +5. 8.99 million kg of plastic scrap exported, far below the biggest exporters reviewed; recorded transport still carries handling work. A US$3.31m plastic scrap import stream is documented; risk judgment moderated by smaller available trade observations. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Previous evidence-backed harm/repair rail retained; waste double-count avoided. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Previous evidence-backed harm/repair rail retained; waste double-count avoided. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Previous verified mutuality assessment retained; no automatic aid bonus from trade. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Previous verified mutuality assessment retained; no automatic aid bonus from trade. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Previous verified positive-contribution assessment retained; this rail is distinct from transferred waste. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Previous verified positive-contribution assessment retained; this rail is distinct from transferred waste. Source-linked authored TBF judgment. Plastic scrap trade and reusable garments are differentiated: a shipment is not presumed to be illegal dumping.
Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents about 15 bilateral projects since 2004 involving health systems, rehabilitation, water-catchment cisterns, farming, and local technical training; completed outputs support positive contribution but do not by themselves quantify all long-run local outcomes.
The headline TBF Abundance Score changed after the underlying published country dataset changed.
TBF points-60.50 → -60.98
Earlier score events did not preserve an exact category-by-category diff. Review detailed category change events recorded after the new history audit was activated.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #107 to #110 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#107 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.98
Countries that moved ahead of this country (3)
- Sri Lanka #108 → #107; -60.54 → -60.54 points
- Germany #109 → #108; -60.57 → -60.57 points
- Belize #110 → #109; -60.77 → -60.77 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#110 → #103National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 12:03 GMT-0500; 1 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #110 to #103 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#110 → #103National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (7)
- Dominican Republic #104 → #104; -60.39 → -61.13 points
- Fiji #106 → #105; -60.41 → -61.15 points
- Belize #109 → #107; -60.77 → -61.49 points
- Germany #108 → #108; -60.57 → -61.73 points
- Sri Lanka #107 → #109; -60.54 → -61.79 points
- Anguilla #99 → #117; -59.73 → -62.28 points
- Turks and Caicos Islands #105 → #123; -60.39 → -62.93 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #108 to #103 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#108 → #103National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (5)
- Dominican Republic #102 → #104; -60.39 → -61.13 points
- Fiji #104 → #105; -60.41 → -61.15 points
- Germany #107 → #108; -60.57 → -61.73 points
- Sri Lanka #106 → #109; -60.54 → -60.54 points
- Turks and Caicos Islands #103 → #123; -60.39 → -60.39 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Rank#109 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#103 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #102 to #101 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#102 → #101National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #103 to #102 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#103 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#102 → #101National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #103 to #102 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#103 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #101 to #102 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#101 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #101 to #103 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#101 → #103National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#101 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 12 Oct 2026 · 05:13 GMT-0500; 5 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#102 → #103National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 12 Oct 2026 · 05:13 GMT-0500; 7 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#103 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 12 Oct 2026 · 05:13 GMT-0500; 3 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#102 → #103National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 12 Oct 2026 · 06:17 GMT-0500; 1292 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#103 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #103 to #102 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#103 → #102National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Azerbaijan #91 → #142; -60.06 → -60.06 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#102 → #101National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #102 to #101 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#102 → #101National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Georgia #94 → #124; -60.23 → -63.73 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#101 → #100National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #101 to #100 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#101 → #100National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Bosnia and Herzegovina #92 → #125; -60.12 → -63.76 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#100 → #99National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #100 to #99 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#100 → #99National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Albania #85 → #126; -59.70 → -63.80 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#99 → #98National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #99 to #98 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#99 → #98National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Armenia #73 → #99; -58.78 → -61.05 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#98 → #97National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #98 to #97 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#98 → #97National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Russia #77 → #149; -59.04 → -66.52 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#97 → #96National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #97 to #96 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#97 → #96National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Japan #94 → #106; -60.65 → -62.02 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#96 → #95National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #96 to #95 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#96 → #95National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- South Korea #55 → #117; -57.70 → -63.36 points
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #97 to #95 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#97 → #95National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- Japan #94 → #105; -60.65 → -62.02 points
- South Korea #55 → #117; -57.70 → -57.70 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#95 → #94National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #95 to #94 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#95 → #94National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- North Macedonia #86 → #238; -59.97 → -59.97 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#94 → #93National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #94 to #93 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#94 → #93National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Italy #34 → #230; -55.14 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#93 → #92National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #93 to #92 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#93 → #92National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Mauritius #74 → #231; -58.97 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#92 → #91National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #92 to #91 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#92 → #91National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Brunei #15 → #220; -50.29 → -50.29 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#91 → #90National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #91 to #90 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#91 → #90National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Tokelau #2 → #241; -45.46 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#90 → #89National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #90 to #89 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#90 → #89National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- San Marino #3 → #236; -47.91 → — points
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #91 to #89 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#91 → #89National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- San Marino #4 → #236; -47.91 → -47.91 points
- Tokelau #2 → #241; -45.46 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#89 → #88National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #89 to #88 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#89 → #88National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Falkland Islands #3 → #217; -48.57 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#88 → #87National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #88 to #87 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#88 → #87National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Liechtenstein #3 → #223; -48.73 → -48.73 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#87 → #86National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #87 to #86 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#87 → #86National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Saint Pierre and Miquelon #6 → #235; -49.61 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#86 → #85National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #86 to #85 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#86 → #85National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Montenegro #48 → #227; -57.74 → -57.74 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#85 → #84National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #85 to #84 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#85 → #84National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Barbados #62 → #206; -58.52 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#84 → #83National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #84 to #83 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#84 → #83National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Maldives #44 → #221; -57.08 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#83 → #82National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #83 to #82 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#83 → #82National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Andorra #9 → #196; -49.97 → -49.97 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#82 → #81National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #82 to #81 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#82 → #81National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Bhutan #70 → #197; -59.75 → -59.75 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#81 → #80National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #81 to #80 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#81 → #80National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Serbia #52 → #231; -58.17 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#80 → #79National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #79 to #78 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#79 → #78National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Slovenia #64 → #232; -59.14 → — points
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #80 to #79 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#80 → #79National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Latvia #52 → #212; -58.21 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#79 → #78National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #80 to #78 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#80 → #78National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#78 → #77National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #77 to #76 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#77 → #76National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Lithuania #49 → #213; -58.05 → — points
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #78 to #77 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#78 → #77National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Guyana #72 → #204; -60.33 → — points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#77 → #81National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #76 to #81 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#76 → #81National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries now above with no previous rank on record (5)
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#81 → #89National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #81 to #89 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#81 → #89National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries now above with no previous rank on record (8)
- Lithuania — → #46; — → -57.53 points
- Montenegro — → #47; — → -57.69 points
- South Korea — → #48; — → -57.70 points
- Latvia — → #54; — → -58.23 points
- Barbados — → #57; — → -58.35 points
- Slovenia — → #68; — → -59.21 points
- Serbia — → #73; — → -59.73 points
- Armenia — → #86; — → -60.75 points
Recorded rank movement.
Rank#89 → #92National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #89 to #99 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#89 → #99National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries now above with no previous rank on record (10)
- Tokelau — → #2; — → -45.50 points
- San Marino — → #4; — → -47.91 points
- Falkland Islands — → #5; — → -48.59 points
- Liechtenstein — → #6; — → -48.73 points
- Saint Pierre and Miquelon — → #10; — → -49.63 points
- Andorra — → #14; — → -49.97 points
- Brunei — → #15; — → -50.29 points
- Italy — → #36; — → -55.29 points
- Maldives — → #51; — → -57.08 points
- Russia — → #75; — → -59.04 points
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #89 to #92 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#89 → #92National score-60.98 → -60.98
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries now above with no previous rank on record (3)
- San Marino — → #3; — → -47.91 points
- Liechtenstein — → #4; — → -48.73 points
- Brunei — → #11; — → -50.29 points
Every recorded change
Each archived event is preserved. Category details and sources begin from the first detailed country snapshot; older records remain visible without invented comparisons.
Published evidence, observations or country data changed. The headline score did not materially change in this update.
First-ten source-led methodology v3.0 reset: person-level work evidence and all four transboundary trade lanes added. Transfer outcomes and nationally comparable person-level time need further verification before new weighted scoring. Earlier scores and rankings retained; no zero-harm deductions invented.
National points: -60.50 → -60.50; Rank: #107 → #107
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 14.00 | 14.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil does not show an extreme national long-hours profile, but informality, commuting and labour underutilisation mean productivity does not return equally as secure family time.
Sources archived before (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Sources archived after the change (5)
IBGE PNAD Contínua Q2 2025 records informal employment at 37.8% and self-employment at 25.2%. These are employment conditions, not a measured multiple-jobholder rate.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Sources archived with this rescan (10)
IBGE PNAD Contínua Q2 2025 records informal employment at 37.8% and self-employment at 25.2%. These are employment conditions, not a measured multiple-jobholder rate.
Brazil — 2024 export of plastic waste and scrap. 2024 Brazil exported 8,987,510 kg of plastic waste/scrap and separately recorded plastic-scrap imports valued at US$3.31m; exporter and importer responsibilities require independent examination. The customs heading identifies traded material; neither permitted recycling nor proven harmful dumping follows from the heading. Source-level trade measurement is verified, downstream disposition is not.
Brazil — 2024 export of worn clothing and other worn articles. 2024 customs code 630900 can identify worn clothing trade, but no usable-share inspection was verified in this pass. A worn garment can be useful or trash; this audit has no shipment sorting/usable-share or recipient-facility record proving either outcome.
Brazil — 2024 import of plastic waste and scrap. 2024 Brazil exported 8,987,510 kg of plastic waste/scrap and separately recorded plastic-scrap imports valued at US$3.31m; exporter and importer responsibilities require independent examination. The customs heading identifies traded material; neither permitted recycling nor proven harmful dumping follows from the heading. Source-level trade measurement is verified, downstream disposition is not.
Brazil — 2024 import of worn clothing and other worn articles. 2024 customs code 630900 can identify worn clothing trade, but no usable-share inspection was verified in this pass. A worn garment can be useful or trash; this audit has no shipment sorting/usable-share or recipient-facility record proving either outcome.
Existing direct Money Gate result 0.50/4 retained. PNAE provides school food nationwide to public basic-education students; ordinary household food remains payment-gated. School food earns the TBF 0.5/4 allowance. This source supports the earlier audit; no fresh category score or universal no-payment claim is inferred.
Existing direct Money Gate result 1.00/4 retained. Incra agrarian-reform settlements provide an actual conditional path to productive rural plots for selected eligible families. MCMV subsidized housing still usually requires financing or household contribution. This source supports the earlier audit; no fresh category score or universal no-payment claim is inferred.
Existing direct Money Gate result 3.50/4 retained. SUS provides nationwide universal public healthcare without direct patient fees, including primary and specialist services. Queues, coverage unevenness and gaps in access keep this below 4/4. This source supports the earlier audit; no fresh category score or universal no-payment claim is inferred.
Existing direct Money Gate result 0.50/4 retained. Fare-free or discounted interstate journeys for specific eligible groups exist; nationwide ordinary urban/regional travel is not fare-free. This source supports the earlier audit; no fresh category score or universal no-payment claim is inferred.
Existing direct Money Gate result 1.00/4 retained. Luz do Povo guarantees no electricity consumption charge on up to 80kWh a month for qualifying low-income households; this is means-tested and household water remains generally charged. This source supports the earlier audit; no fresh category score or universal no-payment claim is inferred.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #108 to #107 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#108 → #107National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Kazakhstan #92 → #133; -58.99 → -58.99 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #109 to #108 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#109 → #108National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Malaysia #99 → #132; -59.44 → -59.44 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #110 to #109 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#110 → #109National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Taiwan #94 → #126; -59.23 → -62.10 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #110 to #109 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#110 → #109National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Taiwan #94 → #126; -59.23 → -59.23 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #111 to #110 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#111 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Türkiye #102 → #117; -59.72 → -59.72 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #110 to #111 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#110 → #111National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that moved ahead of this country (1)
- India #122 → #104; -61.80 → -59.89 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #111 to #110 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#111 → #110National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Germany #103 → #112; -59.98 → -60.57 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #112 to #111 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank#112 → #111National score-60.50 → -60.50
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- China #93 → #129; -59.17 → -62.31 points
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from pending to 20.25. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | — | 20.25 |
| Base category score | — | 20.25 |
| Research coverage (%) | — | 86.00 |
| Category weight (%) | — | 6.00 |
| Positive Contribution (25%) | — | 65.00 |
| Mutuality / Local Benefit (25%) | — | 50.00 |
| Documented Harm / Extraction (35%) | — | -35.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | — | 25.00 |
Updated reasoning: Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents South-South institutional capacity building, including Brazil–Haiti health services, rehabilitation, water and training, with partner participation. Deforestation and commodity-related ecological impacts create real cross-border concerns, and independently verified long-run mutuality is incomplete. Scoring values are a TBF normative assessment of the cited evidence, not a claim that assistance quantity equals verified benefit.
Sources archived after the change (1)
Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents about 15 bilateral projects since 2004 involving health systems, rehabilitation, water-catchment cisterns, farming, and local technical training; completed outputs support positive contribution but do not by themselves quantify all long-run local outcomes.
Water & Sanitation Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Water & Sanitation Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 17.00 | 17.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: A water-rich country still has a material gap between physical water endowment and safely managed household water, sanitation and wastewater treatment.
Sources archived before (3)
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Safely managed drinking water. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 30.75 | 30.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil possesses extraordinary natural and cultural beauty and positive life-evaluation evidence. Everyday Delight Reach still needs deeper national and municipal evidence.
Sources archived before (2)
World Happiness Report position: 32.00000000
Average life evaluation: 6.63400000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average life evaluation. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
World Happiness Report position: 32.00000000
Average life evaluation: 6.63400000
Mobility & Reachability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Mobility & Reachability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 13.00 | 13.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has extensive movement infrastructure, but commuting burden, road mortality and unequal spatial access reduce the amount of mobility that returns usable time.
Sources archived before (2)
Road traffic mortality rate: 15.70000000
People travelling to work: 71.20000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: People travelling to work. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Road traffic mortality rate: 15.70000000
People travelling to work: 71.20000000
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 29.75 | 29.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil begins with exceptional biological abundance. Recent deforestation direction improved, while substantial absolute living-ground loss remains.
Sources archived before (3)
Deforestation detected: 984794.00000000
Forest area: 59.00000000
Brazilian agricultural publication examined the family’s Foodway, productive diversity, soil cover, public food and resilience thinking.
Sources archived after the change (4)
INPE consolidated the 2025 Amazon Legal deforestation rate at 5,731 km², 12.07% lower than 2024; the earlier October 2025 estimate was 5,796 km². The previously published 2025 Cerrado estimate was 7,235 km². These remain sizeable habitat losses despite improvement.
Deforestation detected: 984794.00000000
Forest area: 59.00000000
Brazilian agricultural publication examined the family’s Foodway, productive diversity, soil cover, public food and resilience thinking.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 22.25 | 22.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has extraordinary land capacity. TBF distinguishes that from ordinary families having practical access to productive land and services outside major commercial centres.
Sources archived before (3)
Agricultural establishment area held by establishments ≥1,000 ha: 47.60000000
Population living in urban areas: 88.00000000
Land area: 8.36000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Incra confirms settlement plots are allocated to selected rural families without means to purchase land; a selection process, registration and settlement-specific rules apply, so this is an actual conditional route, not universal open land access.
Agricultural establishment area held by establishments ≥1,000 ha: 47.60000000
Population living in urban areas: 88.00000000
Land area: 8.36000000
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -4.50 | -4.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Lethal violence has improved but remains a major source of human friction. Public safety and dependable justice are essential abundance conditions.
Sources archived before (3)
World Justice Project position: 78.00000000
Recorded homicides: 42590.00000000
Homicide rate: 20.10000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Atlas da Violencia 2026 reports 42,590 homicides in 2024, 20.1 per 100,000 (-7.4% from 2023); this improves direction but remains a major public-safety burden.
World Justice Project position: 78.00000000
Recorded homicides: 42590.00000000
Homicide rate: 20.10000000
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 70.25 | 70.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil combines broad visitor access with unusually practical migrant-life pathways: CPF access, bank-account possibility, temporary use of foreign driving licences, MERCOSUR residence, frontier regularisation and humanitarian residence routes. Visa requirements and financial-institution discretion keep the score below deep-abundance levels.
Sources archived before (6)
Brazil maintains specific residence pathways for neighbouring nationals and humanitarian situations including Haiti, Syria, Afghanistan and Ukraine
Nationals of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay may obtain temporary residence; eligible temporary residence can become indefinite after two years
Foreign driving licence usability: 180.00000000
Non-residents may open real-denominated accounts at institutions authorised for foreign exchange; institutions retain onboarding discretion
Foreign residents and non-residents may apply for CPF; registration is free through Receita channels
Broad visa-free list; eVisa available to Australia, Canada and United States
Sources archived after the change (7)
Brazil requires nationals of Australia, Canada and the US to obtain an eVisa for tourism/business from 10 April 2025. This is an online visa rather than visa-free access and does not imply eligibility for all foreign nationals.
Brazil maintains specific residence pathways for neighbouring nationals and humanitarian situations including Haiti, Syria, Afghanistan and Ukraine
Nationals of Argentina, Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, Paraguay, Peru and Uruguay may obtain temporary residence; eligible temporary residence can become indefinite after two years
Foreign driving licence usability: 180.00000000
Non-residents may open real-denominated accounts at institutions authorised for foreign exchange; institutions retain onboarding discretion
Foreign residents and non-residents may apply for CPF; registration is free through Receita channels
Broad visa-free list; eVisa available to Australia, Canada and United States
Human Time & Burden Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 14.00 | 14.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil does not show an extreme national long-hours profile, but informality, commuting and labour underutilisation mean productivity does not return equally as secure family time.
Sources archived before (3)
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Average actual work week. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Informal employment: 38.10000000
Workers above 48 hours per week: 9.90000000
Average actual work week: 38.90000000
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 2.50 | 2.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Extensive housing capacity coexists with vacant dwellings, a large housing deficit and people living in street situations. Stock alone therefore does not establish shelter abundance.
Sources archived before (3)
People registered in street situation: 327925.00000000
Estimated housing deficit: 6.22000000
Vacant private dwellings: 11.40000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Vacant private dwellings. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
People registered in street situation: 327925.00000000
Estimated housing deficit: 6.22000000
Vacant private dwellings: 11.40000000
Health & Care Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Health & Care Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 38.80 | 38.80 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has substantial public-health capacity and strong service coverage, while maternal and child outcomes show remaining gaps between capability and lived health.
Sources archived before (3)
Under-five mortality rate: 14.59000000
Maternal mortality ratio: 66.90000000
Universal health coverage service index: 84.00000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Brazil Health Ministry states that SUS guarantees universal comprehensive free healthcare from prevention and primary care to complex hospital treatment; geographic queues and service performance must be evaluated separately.
Under-five mortality rate: 14.59000000
Maternal mortality ratio: 66.90000000
Universal health coverage service index: 84.00000000
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 25.30 | 25.30 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil has formidable food capacity and household food security improved in 2024, but nourishment still does not reach every household. Free Food Reach remains a TBF-native research layer.
Sources archived before (3)
Households with severe food insecurity: 3.20000000
Households with any food insecurity: 24.20000000
Food-secure households: 75.80000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
IBGE-based 2024 food-security reporting shows 75.8% of households food secure and 3.2% in severe insecurity; universal school meals reach students, not free everyday food for all households.
Households with severe food insecurity: 3.20000000
Households with any food insecurity: 24.20000000
Food-secure households: 75.80000000
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -49.00 | -49.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Brazil continues to form large numbers of families, while fertility is below replacement, couple-with-children family forms have declined and parental-time supports remain uneven.
Sources archived before (5)
Families consisting of couples with children: 42.00000000
Total fertility rate: 1.55000000
Registered divorces: 428301.00000000
Registered marriages: 948925.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Sources archived after the change (6)
IBGE 2022 Census published 2025 records a total fertility rate of 1.55 children per woman, substantially below replacement and the authored 5.0 target; this is an observed demographic measure, not proof of cause.
Families consisting of couples with children: 42.00000000
Total fertility rate: 1.55000000
Registered divorces: 428301.00000000
Registered marriages: 948925.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Energy & Household Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Energy & Household Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 64.05 | 64.05 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Near-universal electricity and high clean-cooking access show a strong example of infrastructure capability reaching household life.
Sources archived before (2)
Access to clean cooking fuels and technologies: 96.50000000
Access to electricity: 99.80000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
The Luz do Povo social electricity tariff provides an allowance of up to 80 kWh monthly with no consumption charge to eligible CadUnico and other qualifying households; above-threshold consumption and other charges may still apply.
Access to clean cooking fuels and technologies: 96.50000000
Access to electricity: 99.80000000
Education & Human Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Education & Human Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 21.80 | 21.80 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: School participation is very high, but foundational learning and practical civilization capability remain distinct from attendance.
Sources archived before (4)
Learning poverty estimate: 47.00000000
Adult illiteracy age 15+: 4.90000000
School attendance ages 6–14: 99.50000000
Brazilian publication carried the family’s proposal to connect local digital capability, youth training, tourism and biodiversity documentation in Prado.
Sources archived after the change (5)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: School attendance ages 6–14. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Learning poverty estimate: 47.00000000
Adult illiteracy age 15+: 4.90000000
School attendance ages 6–14: 99.50000000
Brazilian publication carried the family’s proposal to connect local digital capability, youth training, tourism and biodiversity documentation in Prado.
Durability, Repair & Material Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Durability, Repair & Material Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -14.50 | -14.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: Waste collection capacity is high, but environmentally adequate final disposal and broader material-return systems remain far from a deeply circular civilization.
Sources archived before (2)
Environmentally adequate final disposal: 59.70000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 81.60000000
Sources archived after the change (3)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Municipal solid waste generated. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Environmentally adequate final disposal: 59.70000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 81.60000000
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate) changed from 3.18 to 6.5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate)
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 3.18 | 6.50 |
| Food / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Housing / Land / 4 | — | 1.00 |
| Healthcare / 4 | — | 3.50 |
| Transportation / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Water / Energy / 4 | — | 1.00 |
Category point adjustment: +3.32 category points
Earlier reasoning: Transitional proxy or benchmark; no invented five-part direct audit.
Updated reasoning: {"food":"PNAE provides school food nationwide to public basic-education students; ordinary household food remains payment-gated. School food earns the TBF 0.5\/4 allowance.","housing_land":"Incra agrarian-reform settlements provide an actual conditional path to productive rural plots for selected eligible families. MCMV subsidized housing still usually requires financing or household contribution.","healthcare":"SUS provides nationwide universal public healthcare without direct patient fees, including primary and specialist services. Queues, coverage unevenness and gaps in access keep this below 4\/4.","transportation":"Fare-free or discounted interstate journeys for specific eligible groups exist; nationwide ordinary urban\/regional travel is not fare-free.","water_energy":"Luz do Povo guarantees no electricity consumption charge on up to 80kWh a month for qualifying low-income households; this is means-tested and household water remains generally charged."}
Sources archived after the change (6)
The headline TBF Abundance Score changed after the underlying published country dataset changed.
TBF points-64.46 → -60.50
Earlier score events did not preserve an exact category-by-category diff. Review detailed category change events recorded after the new history audit was activated.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from pending to 20.25. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | — | 20.25 |
| Base category score | — | 20.25 |
| Research coverage (%) | — | 86.00 |
| Category weight (%) | — | 6.00 |
| Positive Contribution (25%) | — | 65.00 |
| Mutuality / Local Benefit (25%) | — | 50.00 |
| Documented Harm / Extraction (35%) | — | -35.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | — | 25.00 |
Updated reasoning: Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents South-South institutional capacity building, including Brazil–Haiti health services, rehabilitation, water and training, with partner participation. Deforestation and commodity-related ecological impacts create real cross-border concerns, and independently verified long-run mutuality is incomplete. Scoring values are a TBF normative assessment of the cited evidence, not a claim that assistance quantity equals verified benefit.
Sources archived after the change (1)
Brazilian Cooperation Agency documents about 15 bilateral projects since 2004 involving health systems, rehabilitation, water-catchment cisterns, farming, and local technical training; completed outputs support positive contribution but do not by themselves quantify all long-run local outcomes.
Water & Sanitation Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Water & Sanitation Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 17.00 | 17.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning: A water-rich country still has a material gap between physical water endowment and safely managed household water, sanitation and wastewater treatment.
Sources archived before (3)
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
Sources archived after the change (4)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Safely managed drinking water. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Domestic wastewater safely treated: 43.40000000
Safely managed sanitation: 55.00000000
Safely managed drinking water: 88.60000000
and then 
