Earliest recorded position in this interval.
World Wealthiest Country · Abundance history
United States of America 🇺🇸 · Country History
Movement in the World Wealthiest Country Abundance Scorecard, measured through access to life rather than GDP or money. Every archived point adjustment and source remains available; unchanged observations are condensed by date, not deleted.
World Wealthiest Country · Recorded rank history
78 meaningful rank/score point(s)Dated changes with readable spacing · diagonal lines show rank movement · horizontal lines show held positions · scroll left for earlier dates.
National score over the same dates
The rank can hold while points move. This chart shows only actually recorded score readings; its vertical scale follows the visible minimum and maximum.
Dots mark initial readings and rank or score changes; unchanged readings extend a dated interval. Select a dot for the score and related archived events.
Selected rank observation
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #200 to #203 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #203 to #209 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
National score changed while rank held.
Held through 9 Oct 2026 · 07:51 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 10 Oct 2026 · 14:15 GMT-0500; 1 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #209 to #212 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
National score changed while rank held.
Held through 11 Oct 2026 · 12:02 GMT-0500; 67 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome changed from pending to -26.5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | — | -26.50 |
| Base category score | — | -26.50 |
| Research coverage (%) | — | 90.00 |
| Category weight (%) | — | 6.00 |
| Entry Accessibility (25%) | — | -35.00 |
| Migrant Practical Life (30%) | — | 25.00 |
| Refugee / Neighbour Welcome (25%) | — | -65.00 |
| Flexibility / Continuity (20%) | — | -45.00 |
Updated reasoning
The US retains pathways for many visitors, migrants and family members but 2026 nationality-based visa restrictions now cover 39 countries. Refugee and family-entry continuity are constrained. Under the four published welcome rails, capacity does not establish accessible entry, and restrictions receive a negative reach/continuity judgment. Immigration impacts vary by nationality and visa type; the review does not treat a denied visa as an observed fertility effect.
Sources archived after the change (12)
The LuvYou Care-Port and distributed-nuclei work treats visitors, migrants, learners and refugees as people who should retain practical access to movement, family care and ordinary participation.
Refugee Processing Center data record 12,904 refugee arrivals during FY2026 through August 31. The figure is partial-year and sits beside the separate 39-country visa/entry restrictions already recorded.
The Department of State states that a January 2026 pause of immigrant visa issuance to nationals of 75 countries was no longer in effect as of August 21, 2026 following a court order. This separate pause is therefore not counted as a current restriction in the America baseline.
US State Department confirms full or partial suspensions affecting 39 countries from January 2026, with limited exceptions and altered family-visa routes; these current restrictions lower verified welcome reach.
The Department of State states that Presidential Proclamation 10998, effective January 1, 2026, fully or partially suspended entry and visa issuance for nationals of 39 countries and for people applying with Palestinian Authority travel documents, subject to limited exceptions.
The Department of State reported that the United States resettled 100,000 refugees in fiscal year 2024. Current FY2026 reporting is retained separately because the policy environment changed after 2024.
Afghan and Iraqi SIV arrivals receiving resettlement benefits, FY2026 through August 31: 2645.00000000
USRAP refugee arrivals, FY2026 through August 31: 12904.00000000
August 31, 2026
Refugees resettled through USRAP: 100000.00000000
Countries subject to full or partial entry/visa suspension under Proclamation 10998: 39.00000000
Visa Waiver Program maximum stay for eligible visitors: 90.00000000
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from pending to 0.5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | — | 0.50 |
| Base category score | — | 0.50 |
| Research coverage (%) | — | 84.00 |
| Category weight (%) | — | 6.00 |
| Positive Contribution (25%) | — | 65.00 |
| Mutuality / Local Benefit (25%) | — | 15.00 |
| Documented Harm / Extraction (35%) | — | -45.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | — | -25.00 |
Updated reasoning
OECD identifies USD 29bn in 2025 ODA, a substantial absolute outward contribution, but 2025 aid contracted 56.9% in real terms. Broader consumption emissions and external harms warrant negative scrutiny, while local mutuality and repair are insufficiently demonstrated. These four rails are a transparent TBF qualitative judgment, not a causal estimate of specific international harms.
Sources archived after the change (12)
The Distributed Founding Nuclei strategy treats external expansion as successful when it transfers useful capability, supports local roots and avoids organizing other people around extraction.
OECD reports preliminary 2025 US ODA of USD 29 billion (0.09% of GNI), down 56.9% in real terms compared with 2024; positive provision remains material but fell sharply. The evidence alone does not establish downstream local benefit or all cross-border impacts.
OECD preliminary data report USD 29 billion of U.S. official development assistance in 2025, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% in real terms from 2024. This is retained as measurable contribution evidence without turning foreign-policy choices into a TBF numeric verdict.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
OECD reports U.S. ODA at 0.23% of GNI in 2024 and preliminary 2025 ODA of USD 29.0 billion, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% from 2024. The release stores the measurable contribution without converting it into an overall external-conduct judgment.
Real-terms change in official development assistance: -56.90000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI, preliminary: 0.09000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions per capita: 15.80000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions: 5.43000000
Official development assistance, preliminary: 29.00000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI: 0.23000000
Water & Sanitation Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Water & Sanitation Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 29.50 | 29.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
Household plumbing reach remains very high and most public water systems reported no drinking-water violations in 2024. The deeper pass nevertheless counts the infrastructure burden directly: 31% of active public water systems reported at least one violation, 7% had a health-based violation, EPA estimates 9.2 million lead service lines, and the 20-year drinking-water infrastructure need is $625 billion. Under the TBF water-intelligence standard, high capacity therefore earns less credit when safe reach still depends on a large repair backlog.
Sources archived before (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats water abundance as reliable household access plus capture, storage, reuse and redundancy; national water volume alone does not satisfy the standard.
Estimated lead service lines: 9.20000000
Twenty-year drinking-water infrastructure need: 625.00000000
Active public water systems with a health-based violation: 7.00000000
Active public water systems with no reported drinking-water violations: 69.00000000
Housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 98.43000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats water abundance as reliable household access plus capture, storage, reuse and redundancy; national water volume alone does not satisfy the standard.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Housing units with complete plumbing facilities. Calculated from 144,437,207 of 146,740,964 housing units.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Estimated lead service lines: 9.20000000
Twenty-year drinking-water infrastructure need: 625.00000000
Active public water systems with a health-based violation: 7.00000000
Active public water systems with no reported drinking-water violations: 69.00000000
Housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 98.43000000
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 7.25 | 7.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
The United States has enormous recreational and cultural capacity, including 433 National Park Service areas and more than 323 million recreation visits in 2025. The household-life reading is much weaker: CDC reports 12.5% of adults regularly experiencing worry, nervousness or anxiety in 2025 and a final 2024 age-adjusted suicide rate of 13.7 per 100,000. The category therefore keeps credit for accessible public nature while sharply reducing the assumption that national amenity capacity equals everyday peace of mind.
Sources archived before (5)
Balushu and related civilization work treat beauty, nature, recreation and peaceful public life as ordinary provisions rather than luxuries families must continually purchase.
Age-adjusted suicide rate: 13.70000000
Adults regularly reporting worry, nervousness or anxiety: 12.50000000
National Park Service areas: 433.00000000
National Park Service recreation visits: 323014305.00000000
Sources archived after the change (6)
Balushu and related civilization work treat beauty, nature, recreation and peaceful public life as ordinary provisions rather than luxuries families must continually purchase.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: National Park Service recreation visits. NPS recorded 323,014,305 recreation visits in 2025. NPS notes a 43-day partial federal government shutdown during the year; 406 of 433 park units reported visitation figures.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Age-adjusted suicide rate: 13.70000000
Adults regularly reporting worry, nervousness or anxiety: 12.50000000
National Park Service areas: 433.00000000
National Park Service recreation visits: 323014305.00000000
Mobility & Reachability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Mobility & Reachability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 5.25 | 5.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
America has enormous road, aviation and vehicle capacity, but everyday movement remains strongly car-dependent and time-consuming. Census reports a 27.2-minute mean one-way commute in 2024, 9.3% of workers travelling 60 minutes or more one way, only 3.7% using public transportation and 69.2% driving alone. NHTSA estimates 36,640 road deaths in 2025. Under the TBF reach-and-time standard, physical transport capacity therefore receives much less credit when ordinary movement still requires substantial household time, vehicle dependence and safety exposure.
Sources archived before (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Workers driving alone to work: 69.20000000
Road traffic deaths: 36640.00000000
Workers using public transportation to commute: 3.70000000
Workers travelling 60 minutes or more one way: 9.30000000
Mean one-way travel time to work: 27.20000000
Sources archived after the change (8)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Mean one-way travel time to work. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Workers driving alone to work: 69.20000000
Road traffic deaths: 36640.00000000
Workers using public transportation to commute: 3.70000000
Workers travelling 60 minutes or more one way: 9.30000000
Mean one-way travel time to work: 27.20000000
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 6.50 | 6.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
The United States retains vast forests and its net greenhouse-gas emissions are below 2005 levels, but absolute ecological pressure remains large. The latest national wetland status report estimates a net loss of 221,000 acres from 2009 to 2019 and a 670,000-acre loss of vegetated wetlands. Under the TBF living-ground standard, retained natural capacity therefore does not outweigh continuing habitat loss and high material/emissions pressure.
Sources archived before (6)
Life upon Life and AgriGames Foodway judge land use by whether soil, water, shade, habitat and biological activity become stronger through human use.
Net vegetated wetland loss, 2009–2019: 670.00000000
Net wetland loss in the conterminous United States, 2009–2019: 221.00000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions change since 2005: -19.60000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions after land-sector sequestration: 5257.40000000
Forest and woodland area: 823.00000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
Life upon Life and AgriGames Foodway judge land use by whether soil, water, shade, habitat and biological activity become stronger through human use.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Forest and woodland area. Report states approximately 823 million acres of forests and woodlands.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Net vegetated wetland loss, 2009–2019: 670.00000000
Net wetland loss in the conterminous United States, 2009–2019: 221.00000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions change since 2005: -19.60000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions after land-sector sequestration: 5257.40000000
Forest and woodland area: 823.00000000
Land Access & Spatial Freedom supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -7.50 | -7.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
America has enormous physical acreage and low average population density, but this category measures ordinary access to productive ground and settlement freedom. USDA reports average farm real estate at $4,500 per acre in 2026 and a 6.8% nominal annualized rise from 2020 to 2025. Under the TBF spatial-freedom standard, abundant national land no longer receives a strong positive score when practical acquisition and family settlement remain heavily price-gated.
Sources archived before (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats land abundance as practical family access to productive ground and settlement choice, not simply low national density or large acreage totals.
Nominal farm real-estate value compound annual growth, 2020–2025: 6.80000000
National Park System area: 85.00000000
Average farm real estate value: 4500.00000000
Population living in rural areas: 20.00000000
Population density: 93.80000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats land abundance as practical family access to productive ground and settlement choice, not simply low national density or large acreage totals.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population density. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Nominal farm real-estate value compound annual growth, 2020–2025: 6.80000000
National Park System area: 85.00000000
Average farm real estate value: 4500.00000000
Population living in rural areas: 20.00000000
Population density: 93.80000000
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 0.75 | 0.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
Physical safety improved materially in 2025: the FBI final release reports a 9.3% decline in the violent-crime rate and an 18.1% decline in murder and nonnegligent manslaughter. Institutional friction remains substantial in the latest BJS jail series: 658,700 people were held in local jails at midyear 2024 and 68% were unconvicted. The TBF reading therefore preserves the safety improvement while sharply reducing credit for a justice system with large pretrial-custody and administrative burdens.
Sources archived before (5)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats safety as only one part of justice; evidence access, timely hearings, clear public roles and low administrative friction also determine whether justice is usable by ordinary families.
The FBI final 2025 reported-crime release confirms that the national violent-crime rate fell 9.3% from 2024 to 2025, while murder and nonnegligent manslaughter fell 18.1%.
Local jail inmates unconvicted at midyear: 68.00000000
Local jail incarceration rate: 194.00000000
Estimated change in violent crime: -9.30000000
Sources archived after the change (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats safety as only one part of justice; evidence access, timely hearings, clear public roles and low administrative friction also determine whether justice is usable by ordinary families.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Estimated change in violent crime. FBI national estimate: violent-crime rate decreased 9.3% from 2024 to 2025. More than 17,000 agencies covering 96.2% of the U.S. population submitted 2025 data; national estimates do not describe every community.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The FBI final 2025 reported-crime release confirms that the national violent-crime rate fell 9.3% from 2024 to 2025, while murder and nonnegligent manslaughter fell 18.1%.
Local jail inmates unconvicted at midyear: 68.00000000
Local jail incarceration rate: 194.00000000
Estimated change in violent crime: -9.30000000
Human Time & Burden Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -22.50 | -22.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
America has major productive capacity, but this category measures whether that capacity returns usable family time. In 2025 full-time workers averaged 8.07 hours on days worked and 29.6% worked on an average weekend day; only 27% of civilian workers had access to paid family leave in the latest comparable BLS series, and there is still no federal guarantee of paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers. BLS consumer-expenditure data also show housing and transportation absorbing 50.4% of average spending in 2024. Under the TBF family-time standard, capacity therefore no longer outweighs the reach and friction burden.
Sources archived before (7)
The U.S. Department of Labor states that while many workers may qualify for unpaid FMLA leave and some workers receive paid benefits through employers or state programs, there is currently no federal law guaranteeing paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
Housing and transportation share of household spending: 50.40000000
Civilian workers with access to paid family leave: 27.00000000
Full-time workers working on an average weekend day: 29.60000000
Full-time work on days worked: 8.07000000
Sources archived after the change (8)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Full-time work on days worked. BLS 2025 ATUS annual average for full-time workers on days worked; table 4 reports 8.07 hours (rounded to 8.1 hours in the release text).. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The U.S. Department of Labor states that while many workers may qualify for unpaid FMLA leave and some workers receive paid benefits through employers or state programs, there is currently no federal law guaranteeing paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
Housing and transportation share of household spending: 50.40000000
Civilian workers with access to paid family leave: 27.00000000
Full-time workers working on an average weekend day: 29.60000000
Full-time work on days worked: 8.07000000
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -30.00 | -30.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
The United States has enormous physical housing capacity and near-universal plumbing, but shelter reach is materially weaker than stock suggests. In 2024, 46.23% of renter households were cost-burdened, median gross rent reached $1,487 and the median renter spent 31% of income on rent and utilities. Homeownership was 65.0% in Q2 2026, while HUD counted 745,652 people homeless on one night in January 2025. GAO finds institutional investors are a real but limited part of the national picture—about 1–3% of all single-family homes in six studied metros in 2024—so the negative score is driven by affordability and reach, not a claim that large investors own most U.S. homes.
Sources archived before (9)
GAO's 2026 study found institutional investors owned about 1% to 3% of all single-family homes in six selected metropolitan areas in 2024, while their share of single-family rental homes ranged from 4% to 22%. This supports treating institutional ownership as a localized affordability factor without claiming that large investors own most U.S. homes.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Homeownership rate: 65.00000000
Median gross rent: 1487.00000000
Occupied housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 99.59000000
People experiencing homelessness on a single night: 745652.00000000
Renter households spending over 30% of income on housing: 46.23000000
Housing units: 146740964.00000000
Sources archived after the change (10)
GAO's 2026 study found institutional investors owned about 1% to 3% of all single-family homes in six selected metropolitan areas in 2024, while their share of single-family rental homes ranged from 4% to 22%. This supports treating institutional ownership as a localized affordability factor without claiming that large investors own most U.S. homes.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Housing units. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Homeownership rate: 65.00000000
Median gross rent: 1487.00000000
Occupied housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 99.59000000
People experiencing homelessness on a single night: 745652.00000000
Renter households spending over 30% of income on housing: 46.23000000
Housing units: 146740964.00000000
Health & Care Reach supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Health & Care Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 2.50 | 2.50 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
The United States has deep clinical and medical capacity, and 92.1% of people had health insurance for at least part of 2025. Reach is nevertheless heavily friction-loaded: 7.9% were uninsured for the full year, CMS reports $15,474 in health spending per person and $556.6 billion in out-of-pocket spending in 2024, and maternal mortality remained 17.9 per 100,000 live births. CDC final data show life expectancy improved to 79.0 years in 2024, so the score keeps that positive outcome while sharply reducing the credit given to expensive capacity that does not translate cleanly into household reach.
Sources archived before (9)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Life expectancy at birth: 79.00000000
Out-of-pocket health spending: 556.60000000
National health expenditure per person: 15474.00000000
Infant mortality rate: 5.52500000
Maternal mortality rate: 17.90000000
Population uninsured for the full year: 7.90000000
Population with health insurance for all or part of year: 92.10000000
Sources archived after the change (10)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population with health insurance for all or part of year. Calculated as the complement of the Census Bureau estimate that 7.9% of people were uninsured for the entire year in 2025.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Life expectancy at birth: 79.00000000
Out-of-pocket health spending: 556.60000000
National health expenditure per person: 15474.00000000
Infant mortality rate: 5.52500000
Maternal mortality rate: 17.90000000
Population uninsured for the full year: 7.90000000
Population with health insurance for all or part of year: 92.10000000
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -7.75 | -7.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
America has extraordinary food-production capacity, but the category asks whether nourishment actually reaches people and whether abundance is multiplied rather than wasted. USDA reports 13.7% of households were food insecure in 2024 and 5.4% experienced very low food security; EPA states that 30–40% of the U.S. food supply is never eaten. Under the TBF standard, strong physical supply therefore no longer outweighs money-gated reach, food insecurity and large loss/waste.
Sources archived before (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
30–40%
Households with very low food security: 5.40000000
Food-insecure households: 13.70000000
Food-secure households: 86.30000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
USDA 2024 found 13.7% of US households food-insecure and 5.4% with very low food security; the national free-school-meal route does not cover all family nourishment.
30–40%
Households with very low food security: 5.40000000
Food-insecure households: 13.70000000
Food-secure households: 86.30000000
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -76.25 | -76.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
Family households remain common and most family households are married-couple households, which is positive evidence. The continuity picture is nevertheless materially strained under the TBF family-centered standard: one-person households are 29%, fertility is at a record low, paid-family-leave reach is incomplete, and 39.5% of 2024 births were to unmarried women. These indicators do not prove the quality of any individual household; they are used as national family-formation and continuity signals alongside the Trott Bailey Family authored standard.
Sources archived before (8)
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
Births to unmarried women: 39.50000000
Total fertility rate: 1599.50000000
All households that are one-person households: 29.00000000
Family households that are married-couple households: 74.00000000
Households classified as family households: 64.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Sources archived after the change (9)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Households classified as family households. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
Births to unmarried women: 39.50000000
Total fertility rate: 1599.50000000
All households that are one-person households: 29.00000000
Family households that are married-couple households: 74.00000000
Households classified as family households: 64.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Energy & Household Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Energy & Household Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 12.00 | 12.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
The United States has exceptional energy capacity, but household reach and burden return are weaker than production totals suggest. EIA reports 13.4 million residential electricity disconnections for bill nonpayment in 2024, while fossil fuels still supplied about 58% of utility-scale electricity generation in 2025 and renewables were only about 9% of total U.S. energy consumption. The TBF standard therefore separates national production from dependable household capability.
Sources archived before (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization evaluates energy by what it lets households do—cool, cook, pump water, preserve food, move and remove strain—rather than by production totals alone.
Residential electricity disconnections for bill nonpayment: 13.40000000
Utility-scale electricity generated from fossil fuels: 58.00000000
Average electricity interruption duration per customer: 11.00000000
Renewable energy consumption: 8.83000000
Primary energy production: 106.96000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization evaluates energy by what it lets households do—cool, cook, pump water, preserve food, move and remove strain—rather than by production totals alone.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Primary energy production. EIA reported 106.96 quadrillion Btu of total U.S. energy production in 2025; the accompanying article rounds this to 107 quads.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Residential electricity disconnections for bill nonpayment: 13.40000000
Utility-scale electricity generated from fossil fuels: 58.00000000
Average electricity interruption duration per customer: 11.00000000
Renewable energy consumption: 8.83000000
Primary energy production: 106.96000000
Education & Human Capability supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Education & Human Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 12.00 | 12.00 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
Formal educational reach and adult attainment are broad, but foundational outcomes materially weaken the capability reading. In 2024 only 31% of fourth-graders were at or above NAEP Proficient in reading, 40% were below NAEP Basic, and only 28% of eighth-graders were at or above NAEP Proficient in mathematics. Under the NoDumbDumbs capability standard, institutional capacity cannot outweigh weak demonstrated foundational mastery.
Sources archived before (6)
NoDumbDumbs treats education as demonstrated understanding and capability, not years of institutional attendance alone; national attainment is therefore read beside foundational learning outcomes.
Eighth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in mathematics: 28.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Basic in reading: 60.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in reading: 31.00000000
Population age 25+ with bachelor degree or higher: 36.80000000
Population age 25+ with high school education or higher: 89.90000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
NoDumbDumbs treats education as demonstrated understanding and capability, not years of institutional attendance alone; national attainment is therefore read beside foundational learning outcomes.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population age 25+ with high school education or higher. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Eighth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in mathematics: 28.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Basic in reading: 60.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in reading: 31.00000000
Population age 25+ with bachelor degree or higher: 36.80000000
Population age 25+ with high school education or higher: 89.90000000
Durability, Repair & Material Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Durability, Repair & Material Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -7.25 | -7.25 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
The United States has major manufacturing, maintenance and recycling capacity, but national material-return evidence remains weak and dated. EPA’s latest national municipal-waste series reports 292.4 million tons of waste, 4.9 pounds per person per day, a 32.1% recycling/composting rate and only about 9% plastics recycling in 2018. FTC repair findings document multiple forms of repair restriction. The score therefore treats high material throughput and repair friction as substantial losses while keeping coverage at 90% because the national waste series is stale.
Sources archived before (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats repair, maintenance, local skill and material return as civilization capability; high throughput is a burden when useful goods repeatedly become waste.
The Federal Trade Commission identified restrictions including limited spare-parts availability, inaccessible diagnostic software and product designs that make repair more difficult, while finding scant evidence for many manufacturer justifications.
Plastics recycling rate in municipal solid waste: 9.00000000
Municipal solid waste recycling and composting rate: 32.10000000
Municipal solid waste generated per person: 4.90000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 292.40000000
Sources archived after the change (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats repair, maintenance, local skill and material return as civilization capability; high throughput is a burden when useful goods repeatedly become waste.
The Federal Trade Commission identified restrictions including limited spare-parts availability, inaccessible diagnostic software and product designs that make repair more difficult, while finding scant evidence for many manufacturer justifications.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Municipal solid waste generated. EPA national materials series is current through 2018; retained with reduced confidence rather than treated as current-year data.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Plastics recycling rate in municipal solid waste: 9.00000000
Municipal solid waste recycling and composting rate: 32.10000000
Municipal solid waste generated per person: 4.90000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 292.40000000
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate) changed from 1 to 1.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate)
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 1.00 | 1.75 |
| Food / 4 | — | 0.50 |
| Housing / Land / 4 | — | 0.25 |
| Healthcare / 4 | — | 0.75 |
| Transportation / 4 | — | 0.00 |
| Water / Energy / 4 | — | 0.25 |
Category point adjustment: +0.75 category points
Updated reasoning
- Food
- National School Lunch Program provides eligible free school meals; routine household food is purchased. Institutional school food is limited to the TBF 0.5/4 allowance.
- Housing / Land
- HUD housing vouchers are subsidized rent; families ordinarily pay about 30% of adjusted income. This is not universal free housing or free land.
- Healthcare
- EMTALA mandates emergency screening and stabilization without prior payment. Medicaid and other targeted coverage exist, but services may be billed and routine universal no-pay care is absent.
- Transport
- Regular local and intercity travel is generally fare-based. No nationwide ordinary zero-fare baseline documented.
- Water / Energy
- Targeted assistance or moratoria may protect some households; EIA reports residential disconnections for bill nonpayment. No nationwide no-pay utility continuity.
Earlier reasoning
Transitional proxy or benchmark; no invented five-part direct audit.
Sources archived after the change (5)
The headline TBF Abundance Score changed after the underlying published country dataset changed.
Earlier score events did not preserve an exact category-by-category diff. Review detailed category change events recorded after the new history audit was activated.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #212 to #210 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- Gabon #210 → #211; points -74.40 → -75.85
- Turkmenistan #211 → #212; points -74.97 → -76.52
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #212 to #210 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- Gabon #209 → #211; points -74.40 → -75.85
- Turkmenistan #211 → #212; points -74.97 → -74.97
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
National score changed while rank held.
No additional field-by-field change record was found at this date; older missing details are not reconstructed.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #209 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #210 to #209 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #210 to #209 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #208 to #209 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #208 to #210 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #209 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #208 to #207 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #206 to #207 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #207 to #206 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #208 to #209 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #207 to #209 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #206 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #209 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- New Zealand Previously #147; no longer ranked in this snapshot; points -65.36 → -65.36
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #208 to #207 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Hungary Previously #162; no longer ranked in this snapshot; points -67.43 → -67.43
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #206 to #205 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #207 to #206 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #205 to #204 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #206 to #205 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #204 to #203 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Chile Previously #55; no longer ranked in this snapshot; points -57.18 → -57.18
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #203 to #202 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #202 to #206 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded here (not confirmed rank jumps) (1)
- Chile First recorded here at #55; earlier position unavailable; points -57.18 → -57.15
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #202 to #205 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #202 to #204 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 12 Oct 2026 · 06:17 GMT-0500; 1292 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #206 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #205 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer movements were archived for this older rank event.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #204 to #208 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded here (not confirmed rank jumps) (3)
- New Zealand First recorded here at #156; earlier position unavailable; points -65.36 → -66.94
- Hungary First recorded here at #166; earlier position unavailable; points -67.43 → -67.72
- Morocco First recorded here at #197; earlier position unavailable; points -72.08 → -72.08
This older event recorded only one side of the movement. Other crossing countries were not archived and cannot be reliably named.
Recorded rank movement.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 11:57 GMT-0500; 8 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from 0.5 to 5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 0.50 | 5.00 |
| Base category score | 0.50 | 5.00 |
| Research coverage (%) | 84.00 | 100.00 |
| Useful Contribution Abroad (25%) | 65.00 | 50.00 |
| Mutual Benefit Retained (25%) | 15.00 | 25.00 |
| Other Harm & Repair (20%) | -45.00 | -50.00 |
| Material Transfers (export/import roles) (30%) | -25.00 | -12.50 |
Category point adjustment: +4.50 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 16 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted. 3.1 weights 25/25/20/30; rail 4 composite of exporter -25 and importer 0, counted exactly once. Old readings untouched in history. Stored category base score explicitly 5.0 under method 3.1, rather than global older 25/25/35/15 default.
Earlier reasoning
OECD identifies USD 29bn in 2025 ODA, a substantial absolute outward contribution, but 2025 aid contracted 56.9% in real terms. Broader consumption emissions and external harms warrant negative scrutiny, while local mutuality and repair are insufficiently demonstrated. These four rails are a transparent TBF qualitative judgment, not a causal estimate of specific international harms.
Sources archived before (12)
The Distributed Founding Nuclei strategy treats external expansion as successful when it transfers useful capability, supports local roots and avoids organizing other people around extraction.
OECD reports preliminary 2025 US ODA of USD 29 billion (0.09% of GNI), down 56.9% in real terms compared with 2024; positive provision remains material but fell sharply. The evidence alone does not establish downstream local benefit or all cross-border impacts.
OECD preliminary data report USD 29 billion of U.S. official development assistance in 2025, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% in real terms from 2024. This is retained as measurable contribution evidence without turning foreign-policy choices into a TBF numeric verdict.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
OECD reports U.S. ODA at 0.23% of GNI in 2024 and preliminary 2025 ODA of USD 29.0 billion, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% from 2024. The release stores the measurable contribution without converting it into an overall external-conduct judgment.
Real-terms change in official development assistance: -56.90000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI, preliminary: 0.09000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions per capita: 15.80000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions: 5.43000000
Official development assistance, preliminary: 29.00000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI: 0.23000000
Sources archived after the change (20)
United States, category 16, rail 4: -12.5/100. WITS/UN Comtrade reports $264.3m of US plastic-scrap exports and $385.7m imports in 2024; exporter role −25, importer role 0 produce −12.5 average. Lawful trade is not proof of dumping. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Exports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Imports) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -12.5/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 4: -12.5/100. WITS/UN Comtrade reports $264.3m of US plastic-scrap exports and $385.7m imports in 2024; exporter role −25, importer role 0 produce −12.5 average. Lawful trade is not proof of dumping. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Exports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Imports) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -12.5/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 3: -50/100. Large global emissions and international policy effects can impose costs outside the US; specific causal attribution and repair outcomes need recipient-level investigation. −50 is an explicit TBF proxy judgment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 3: -50/100. Large global emissions and international policy effects can impose costs outside the US; specific causal attribution and repair outcomes need recipient-level investigation. −50 is an explicit TBF proxy judgment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 2: +25/100. ODA can support health, development and infrastructure abroad, while recipient control and durable long-term benefit are not established by donor spending totals alone. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 2: +25/100. ODA can support health, development and infrastructure abroad, while recipient control and durable long-term benefit are not established by donor spending totals alone. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 1: +50/100. OECD reports $29bn U.S. ODA in preliminary 2025, down 56.9% year-on-year. Significant direct contributions remain but continuity has weakened. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 1: +50/100. OECD reports $29bn U.S. ODA in preliminary 2025, down 56.9% year-on-year. Significant direct contributions remain but continuity has weakened. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
The Distributed Founding Nuclei strategy treats external expansion as successful when it transfers useful capability, supports local roots and avoids organizing other people around extraction.
OECD reports preliminary 2025 US ODA of USD 29 billion (0.09% of GNI), down 56.9% in real terms compared with 2024; positive provision remains material but fell sharply. The evidence alone does not establish downstream local benefit or all cross-border impacts.
OECD preliminary data report USD 29 billion of U.S. official development assistance in 2025, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% in real terms from 2024. This is retained as measurable contribution evidence without turning foreign-policy choices into a TBF numeric verdict.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
OECD reports U.S. ODA at 0.23% of GNI in 2024 and preliminary 2025 ODA of USD 29.0 billion, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% from 2024. The release stores the measurable contribution without converting it into an overall external-conduct judgment.
Real-terms change in official development assistance: -56.90000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI, preliminary: 0.09000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions per capita: 15.80000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions: 5.43000000
Official development assistance, preliminary: 29.00000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI: 0.23000000
Water & Sanitation Abundance changed from 29.5 to 23.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Water & Sanitation Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 29.50 | 23.75 |
| Base category score | 29.50 | 23.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 90.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 55.00 | 50.00 |
| Friction / Loss (25%) | -55.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Regeneration (15%) | 10.00 | 0.00 |
Category point adjustment: -5.75 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 04 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
Household plumbing reach remains very high and most public water systems reported no drinking-water violations in 2024. The deeper pass nevertheless counts the infrastructure burden directly: 31% of active public water systems reported at least one violation, 7% had a health-based violation, EPA estimates 9.2 million lead service lines, and the 20-year drinking-water infrastructure need is $625 billion. Under the TBF water-intelligence standard, high capacity therefore earns less credit when safe reach still depends on a large repair backlog.
Sources archived before (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats water abundance as reliable household access plus capture, storage, reuse and redundancy; national water volume alone does not satisfy the standard.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Housing units with complete plumbing facilities. Calculated from 144,437,207 of 146,740,964 housing units.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Estimated lead service lines: 9.20000000
Twenty-year drinking-water infrastructure need: 625.00000000
Active public water systems with a health-based violation: 7.00000000
Active public water systems with no reported drinking-water violations: 69.00000000
Housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 98.43000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 04, rail 4: +0/100. Treatment and water-quality monitoring demonstrate basic return capacity, but the EPA national rivers survey found only 28% good biological condition; no nationwide Life-upon-Life circulation inferred. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 4: +0/100. Treatment and water-quality monitoring demonstrate basic return capacity, but the EPA national rivers survey found only 28% good biological condition; no nationwide Life-upon-Life circulation inferred. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 3: -50/100. EPA reports 10,769 water systems with at least one health-based violation; utility bills remain common and interruptions impose burdens. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 3: -50/100. EPA reports 10,769 water systems with at least one health-based violation; utility bills remain common and interruptions impose burdens. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 2: +50/100. Extensive household plumbing and public provision are documented; simultaneous safe-water/sanitation access for every household and the money-free subgroup were not jointly measured here. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 2: +50/100. Extensive household plumbing and public provision are documented; simultaneous safe-water/sanitation access for every household and the money-free subgroup were not jointly measured here. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 1: +75/100. EPA tracks 147,252 active public water systems in 2024; most supply systems operate, but health-based violations and household sanitation disparities persist. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 04, rail 1: +75/100. EPA tracks 147,252 active public water systems in 2024; most supply systems operate, but health-based violations and household sanitation disparities persist. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 04 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats water abundance as reliable household access plus capture, storage, reuse and redundancy; national water volume alone does not satisfy the standard.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Housing units with complete plumbing facilities. Calculated from 144,437,207 of 146,740,964 housing units.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Estimated lead service lines: 9.20000000
Twenty-year drinking-water infrastructure need: 625.00000000
Active public water systems with a health-based violation: 7.00000000
Active public water systems with no reported drinking-water violations: 69.00000000
Housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 98.43000000
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight changed from 7.25 to 18.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Peace of Mind, Happiness, Beauty & Delight
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 7.25 | 18.75 |
| Base category score | 7.25 | 18.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 80.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 10.00 | 25.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -65.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Delight (15%) | 0.00 | 25.00 |
Category point adjustment: +11.50 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 11 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The United States has enormous recreational and cultural capacity, including 433 National Park Service areas and more than 323 million recreation visits in 2025. The household-life reading is much weaker: CDC reports 12.5% of adults regularly experiencing worry, nervousness or anxiety in 2025 and a final 2024 age-adjusted suicide rate of 13.7 per 100,000. The category therefore keeps credit for accessible public nature while sharply reducing the assumption that national amenity capacity equals everyday peace of mind.
Sources archived before (6)
Balushu and related civilization work treat beauty, nature, recreation and peaceful public life as ordinary provisions rather than luxuries families must continually purchase.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: National Park Service recreation visits. NPS recorded 323,014,305 recreation visits in 2025. NPS notes a 43-day partial federal government shutdown during the year; 406 of 433 park units reported visitation figures.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Age-adjusted suicide rate: 13.70000000
Adults regularly reporting worry, nervousness or anxiety: 12.50000000
National Park Service areas: 433.00000000
National Park Service recreation visits: 323014305.00000000
Sources archived after the change (14)
United States, category 11, rail 4: +25/100. ATUS leisure-time data and NPS participation support actual enjoyment for many, without making subjective happiness a measured free public access percentage. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS Time Use Survey: leisure and sports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NPS 2025 Visitation Statistics) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 4: +25/100. ATUS leisure-time data and NPS participation support actual enjoyment for many, without making subjective happiness a measured free public access percentage. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS Time Use Survey: leisure and sports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NPS 2025 Visitation Statistics) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 3: -50/100. Costs, travel, safety, crowding and family time pressures limit ordinary enjoyment of beautiful places; friction estimate uses proxies, not a direct national denial rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS Time Use Survey: leisure and sports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 3: -50/100. Costs, travel, safety, crowding and family time pressures limit ordinary enjoyment of beautiful places; friction estimate uses proxies, not a direct national denial rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS Time Use Survey: leisure and sports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 2: +25/100. Parks and open spaces are widely used, but actual safe local proximity and free access for all people and mobility groups are not nationally proven by NPS visits. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (NPS 2025 Visitation Statistics) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 2: +25/100. Parks and open spaces are widely used, but actual safe local proximity and free access for all people and mobility groups are not nationally proven by NPS visits. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (NPS 2025 Visitation Statistics) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 1: +75/100. National parks, municipal recreation, public streets and cultural facilities show ample physical beauty and recreation capacity. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (NPS 2025 Visitation Statistics) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS Time Use Survey: leisure and sports) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 11, rail 1: +75/100. National parks, municipal recreation, public streets and cultural facilities show ample physical beauty and recreation capacity. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (NPS 2025 Visitation Statistics) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS Time Use Survey: leisure and sports) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 11 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Balushu and related civilization work treat beauty, nature, recreation and peaceful public life as ordinary provisions rather than luxuries families must continually purchase.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: National Park Service recreation visits. NPS recorded 323,014,305 recreation visits in 2025. NPS notes a 43-day partial federal government shutdown during the year; 406 of 433 park units reported visitation figures.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Age-adjusted suicide rate: 13.70000000
Adults regularly reporting worry, nervousness or anxiety: 12.50000000
National Park Service areas: 433.00000000
National Park Service recreation visits: 323014305.00000000
Mobility & Reachability changed from 5.25 to -3.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Mobility & Reachability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 5.25 | -3.75 |
| Base category score | 5.25 | -3.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 85.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 20.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -65.00 | -75.00 |
| Return / Time (15%) | -45.00 | -25.00 |
Category point adjustment: -9.00 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 08 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
America has enormous road, aviation and vehicle capacity, but everyday movement remains strongly car-dependent and time-consuming. Census reports a 27.2-minute mean one-way commute in 2024, 9.3% of workers travelling 60 minutes or more one way, only 3.7% using public transportation and 69.2% driving alone. NHTSA estimates 36,640 road deaths in 2025. Under the TBF reach-and-time standard, physical transport capacity therefore receives much less credit when ordinary movement still requires substantial household time, vehicle dependence and safety exposure.
Sources archived before (8)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Mean one-way travel time to work. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Workers driving alone to work: 69.20000000
Road traffic deaths: 36640.00000000
Workers using public transportation to commute: 3.70000000
Workers travelling 60 minutes or more one way: 9.30000000
Mean one-way travel time to work: 27.20000000
Sources archived after the change (16)
United States, category 08, rail 4: -25/100. Transport enables employment, family visits and public life, but dependence on cost and commuting cannot establish a net family-time return nationally. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 4: -25/100. Transport enables employment, family visits and public life, but dependence on cost and commuting cannot establish a net family-time return nationally. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 3: -75/100. BLS 2024 consumer spending shows average annual household transport costs of $13,318; vehicle ownership, fares, journeys and delays impose heavy burdens. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 3: -75/100. BLS 2024 consumer spending shows average annual household transport costs of $13,318; vehicle ownership, fares, journeys and delays impose heavy burdens. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 2: +0/100. Commuting statistics and household transport costs do not constitute a national denominator for safe, regular, freely available family mobility; neutral reach is an extrapolation. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 2: +0/100. Commuting statistics and household transport costs do not constitute a national denominator for safe, regular, freely available family mobility; neutral reach is an extrapolation. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 1: +75/100. Roads, transit, aviation and other travel networks provide substantial transport capacity, but local service and accessibility vary greatly. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 08, rail 1: +75/100. Roads, transit, aviation and other travel networks provide substantial transport capacity, but local service and accessibility vary greatly. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2024 household transport expenditure) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS commute measure) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 08 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats transport as successful when movement is reachable and gives time back to family life. Long commutes, compulsory car dependence and transport cost therefore count as life friction even where road capacity is large.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Mean one-way travel time to work. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Workers driving alone to work: 69.20000000
Road traffic deaths: 36640.00000000
Workers using public transportation to commute: 3.70000000
Workers travelling 60 minutes or more one way: 9.30000000
Mean one-way travel time to work: 27.20000000
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience changed from 6.5 to -10. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Living Ground, Biodiversity & Resilience
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 6.50 | -10.00 |
| Base category score | 6.50 | -10.00 |
| Capacity (25%) | 75.00 | 50.00 |
| Reach / Ecological Function (35%) | 15.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction / Loss (25%) | -70.00 | -75.00 |
| Return / Regeneration (15%) | 0.00 | -25.00 |
Category point adjustment: -16.50 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 12 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The United States retains vast forests and its net greenhouse-gas emissions are below 2005 levels, but absolute ecological pressure remains large. The latest national wetland status report estimates a net loss of 221,000 acres from 2009 to 2019 and a 670,000-acre loss of vegetated wetlands. Under the TBF living-ground standard, retained natural capacity therefore does not outweigh continuing habitat loss and high material/emissions pressure.
Sources archived before (7)
Life upon Life and AgriGames Foodway judge land use by whether soil, water, shade, habitat and biological activity become stronger through human use.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Forest and woodland area. Report states approximately 823 million acres of forests and woodlands.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Net vegetated wetland loss, 2009–2019: 670.00000000
Net wetland loss in the conterminous United States, 2009–2019: 221.00000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions change since 2005: -19.60000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions after land-sector sequestration: 5257.40000000
Forest and woodland area: 823.00000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 12, rail 4: -25/100. Projects and rules support some restoration, but the measured landscape results do not establish widespread net biodiversity gains or Life upon Life recovery. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 4: -25/100. Projects and rules support some restoration, but the measured landscape results do not establish widespread net biodiversity gains or Life upon Life recovery. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 3: -75/100. EPA found poor nitrogen condition on 44% and phosphorus on 42% of assessed river miles; pollution and carbon emissions are meaningful systemic pressures. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 3: -75/100. EPA found poor nitrogen condition on 44% and phosphorus on 42% of assessed river miles; pollution and carbon emissions are meaningful systemic pressures. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 2: +0/100. EPA national survey measured only 28% of river/stream miles in good biological condition; aquatic condition is a relevant proxy, not a claim only 28% of all U.S. ecosystems function. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA Rivers and Streams 2018-19 Biological Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 2: +0/100. EPA national survey measured only 28% of river/stream miles in good biological condition; aquatic condition is a relevant proxy, not a claim only 28% of all U.S. ecosystems function. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA Rivers and Streams 2018-19 Biological Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 1: +50/100. Protected/natural habitats, ecological research and environmental stewardship exist alongside widespread damaged river habitats. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA Rivers and Streams 2018-19 Biological Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 12, rail 1: +50/100. Protected/natural habitats, ecological research and environmental stewardship exist alongside widespread damaged river habitats. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EPA Rivers and Streams 2018-19 Biological Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA 2024 Drinking Water Systems Compliance) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 12 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Life upon Life and AgriGames Foodway judge land use by whether soil, water, shade, habitat and biological activity become stronger through human use.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Forest and woodland area. Report states approximately 823 million acres of forests and woodlands.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Net vegetated wetland loss, 2009–2019: 670.00000000
Net wetland loss in the conterminous United States, 2009–2019: 221.00000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions change since 2005: -19.60000000
Net greenhouse gas emissions after land-sector sequestration: 5257.40000000
Forest and woodland area: 823.00000000
Land Access & Spatial Freedom changed from -7.5 to 0. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Land Access & Spatial Freedom
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -7.50 | 0.00 |
| Base category score | -7.50 | 0.00 |
| Capacity (25%) | 95.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | -35.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction / Concentration (25%) | -70.00 | -75.00 |
| Return / Productive Ground (15%) | -10.00 | 0.00 |
Category point adjustment: +7.50 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 10 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
America has enormous physical acreage and low average population density, but this category measures ordinary access to productive ground and settlement freedom. USDA reports average farm real estate at $4,500 per acre in 2026 and a 6.8% nominal annualized rise from 2020 to 2025. Under the TBF spatial-freedom standard, abundant national land no longer receives a strong positive score when practical acquisition and family settlement remain heavily price-gated.
Sources archived before (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats land abundance as practical family access to productive ground and settlement choice, not simply low national density or large acreage totals.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population density. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Nominal farm real-estate value compound annual growth, 2020–2025: 6.80000000
National Park System area: 85.00000000
Average farm real estate value: 4500.00000000
Population living in rural areas: 20.00000000
Population density: 93.80000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 10, rail 4: +0/100. Private and public conservation/use create mixed land benefits; no national proof of free productive family grounds with lasting universal stewardship. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Census ACS Housing and Land Costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 4: +0/100. Private and public conservation/use create mixed land benefits; no national proof of free productive family grounds with lasting universal stewardship. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Census ACS Housing and Land Costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA National Rivers and Streams Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 3: -75/100. Real-estate prices, mortgages, rents, land-use rules and tenure limitations add cost and friction; lawful communal and Indigenous tenure is not counted as vacant land. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Census ACS Housing and Land Costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 3: -75/100. Real-estate prices, mortgages, rents, land-use rules and tenure limitations add cost and friction; lawful communal and Indigenous tenure is not counted as vacant land. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Census ACS Housing and Land Costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 2: +0/100. Land is held in public, private, tribal and other arrangements; no nationwide free 50-hectare marriage entitlement or equivalent universal family reach is established. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 2: +0/100. Land is held in public, private, tribal and other arrangements; no nationwide free 50-hectare marriage entitlement or equivalent universal family reach is established. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 1: +75/100. The country has extensive land and functioning property systems, but geographic land totals cannot be equated with available secure family allotments. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Census ACS Housing and Land Costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 10, rail 1: +75/100. The country has extensive land and functioning property systems, but geographic land totals cannot be equated with available secure family allotments. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Census ACS Housing and Land Costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 10 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats land abundance as practical family access to productive ground and settlement choice, not simply low national density or large acreage totals.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population density. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Nominal farm real-estate value compound annual growth, 2020–2025: 6.80000000
National Park System area: 85.00000000
Average farm real estate value: 4500.00000000
Population living in rural areas: 20.00000000
Population density: 93.80000000
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction changed from 0.75 to 8.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Justice, Safety & Institutional Friction
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 0.75 | 8.75 |
| Base category score | 0.75 | 8.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 70.00 | 50.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 10.00 | 25.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -75.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Reliability (15%) | -10.00 | 0.00 |
Category point adjustment: +8.00 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 13 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
Physical safety improved materially in 2025: the FBI final release reports a 9.3% decline in the violent-crime rate and an 18.1% decline in murder and nonnegligent manslaughter. Institutional friction remains substantial in the latest BJS jail series: 658,700 people were held in local jails at midyear 2024 and 68% were unconvicted. The TBF reading therefore preserves the safety improvement while sharply reducing credit for a justice system with large pretrial-custody and administrative burdens.
Sources archived before (6)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats safety as only one part of justice; evidence access, timely hearings, clear public roles and low administrative friction also determine whether justice is usable by ordinary families.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Estimated change in violent crime. FBI national estimate: violent-crime rate decreased 9.3% from 2024 to 2025. More than 17,000 agencies covering 96.2% of the U.S. population submitted 2025 data; national estimates do not describe every community.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The FBI final 2025 reported-crime release confirms that the national violent-crime rate fell 9.3% from 2024 to 2025, while murder and nonnegligent manslaughter fell 18.1%.
Local jail inmates unconvicted at midyear: 68.00000000
Local jail incarceration rate: 194.00000000
Estimated change in violent crime: -9.30000000
Sources archived after the change (14)
United States, category 13, rail 4: +0/100. Working courts and enforceable judgments coexist with WJP criminal justice factor 0.58; Return 0 is a mixed evidence judgment, not an absence of justice. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FBI 2025 Crime in the Nation report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 4: +0/100. Working courts and enforceable judgments coexist with WJP criminal justice factor 0.58; Return 0 is a mixed evidence judgment, not an absence of justice. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FBI 2025 Crime in the Nation report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 3: -50/100. WJP constraint-on-government 0.63 and civil justice 0.62, paired with varying counsel access, support substantial but not total institutional friction. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 3: -50/100. WJP constraint-on-government 0.63 and civil justice 0.62, paired with varying counsel access, support substantial but not total institutional friction. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 2: +25/100. Legal remedies and rights are available across multiple forums; WJP civil justice factor 0.62 shows limitations and cannot be turned into a 62% served claim. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FBI 2025 Crime in the Nation report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 2: +25/100. Legal remedies and rights are available across multiple forums; WJP civil justice factor 0.62 shows limitations and cannot be turned into a 62% served claim. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FBI 2025 Crime in the Nation report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 1: +50/100. Courts, reporting systems and law enforcement operate nationwide; WJP 2025 US rule of law index reports 0.68 and global rank 27/143. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FBI 2025 Crime in the Nation report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 13, rail 1: +50/100. Courts, reporting systems and law enforcement operate nationwide; WJP 2025 US rule of law index reports 0.68 and global rank 27/143. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (WJP United States 2025 Rule of Law Index) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FBI 2025 Crime in the Nation report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 13 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats safety as only one part of justice; evidence access, timely hearings, clear public roles and low administrative friction also determine whether justice is usable by ordinary families.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Estimated change in violent crime. FBI national estimate: violent-crime rate decreased 9.3% from 2024 to 2025. More than 17,000 agencies covering 96.2% of the U.S. population submitted 2025 data; national estimates do not describe every community.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The FBI final 2025 reported-crime release confirms that the national violent-crime rate fell 9.3% from 2024 to 2025, while murder and nonnegligent manslaughter fell 18.1%.
Local jail inmates unconvicted at midyear: 68.00000000
Local jail incarceration rate: 194.00000000
Estimated change in violent crime: -9.30000000
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome changed from -26.5 to -28.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
International Accessibility, Migration & Human Welcome
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -26.50 | -28.75 |
| Base category score | -26.50 | -28.75 |
| Research coverage (%) | 90.00 | 100.00 |
| Entry Accessibility (25%) | -35.00 | 0.00 |
| Migrant Practical Life (30%) | 25.00 | 0.00 |
| Refugee / Neighbour Welcome (25%) | -65.00 | -75.00 |
| Flexibility / Continuity (20%) | -45.00 | -50.00 |
Category point adjustment: -2.25 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 15 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The US retains pathways for many visitors, migrants and family members but 2026 nationality-based visa restrictions now cover 39 countries. Refugee and family-entry continuity are constrained. Under the four published welcome rails, capacity does not establish accessible entry, and restrictions receive a negative reach/continuity judgment. Immigration impacts vary by nationality and visa type; the review does not treat a denied visa as an observed fertility effect.
Sources archived before (12)
The LuvYou Care-Port and distributed-nuclei work treats visitors, migrants, learners and refugees as people who should retain practical access to movement, family care and ordinary participation.
Refugee Processing Center data record 12,904 refugee arrivals during FY2026 through August 31. The figure is partial-year and sits beside the separate 39-country visa/entry restrictions already recorded.
The Department of State states that a January 2026 pause of immigrant visa issuance to nationals of 75 countries was no longer in effect as of August 21, 2026 following a court order. This separate pause is therefore not counted as a current restriction in the America baseline.
US State Department confirms full or partial suspensions affecting 39 countries from January 2026, with limited exceptions and altered family-visa routes; these current restrictions lower verified welcome reach.
The Department of State states that Presidential Proclamation 10998, effective January 1, 2026, fully or partially suspended entry and visa issuance for nationals of 39 countries and for people applying with Palestinian Authority travel documents, subject to limited exceptions.
The Department of State reported that the United States resettled 100,000 refugees in fiscal year 2024. Current FY2026 reporting is retained separately because the policy environment changed after 2024.
Afghan and Iraqi SIV arrivals receiving resettlement benefits, FY2026 through August 31: 2645.00000000
USRAP refugee arrivals, FY2026 through August 31: 12904.00000000
August 31, 2026
Refugees resettled through USRAP: 100000.00000000
Countries subject to full or partial entry/visa suspension under Proclamation 10998: 39.00000000
Visa Waiver Program maximum stay for eligible visitors: 90.00000000
Sources archived after the change (20)
United States, category 15, rail 4: -50/100. Birth on U.S. soil generally carries constitutionally protected citizenship subject to defined exceptions, but access to residence and family unity varies and 2026 restrictions heighten continuity concerns. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. State Department 2026 nationality-specific visa restrictions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 4: -50/100. Birth on U.S. soil generally carries constitutionally protected citizenship subject to defined exceptions, but access to residence and family unity varies and 2026 restrictions heighten continuity concerns. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. State Department 2026 nationality-specific visa restrictions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 3: -75/100. Refugee Processing Center counted 12,904 FY2026 arrivals through August, markedly smaller than FY2024 levels; more restrictive pathways and uncertainty warrant a negative assessment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Refugee Processing Center, FY2026 arrivals to August) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 3: -75/100. Refugee Processing Center counted 12,904 FY2026 arrivals through August, markedly smaller than FY2024 levels; more restrictive pathways and uncertainty warrant a negative assessment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Refugee Processing Center, FY2026 arrivals to August) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 2: +0/100. Immigrants participate in work and family life, yet eligibility, status, benefit and service differences mean ordinary migrant life cannot be assumed universal. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 2: +0/100. Immigrants participate in work and family life, yet eligibility, status, benefit and service differences mean ordinary migrant life cannot be assumed universal. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 1: +0/100. Visa waiver, family and employment categories enable legal entry, alongside nationality-based restrictions taking effect in 2026; policy breadth alone does not prove practical openness. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. State Department 2026 nationality-specific visa restrictions) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 15, rail 1: +0/100. Visa waiver, family and employment categories enable legal entry, alongside nationality-based restrictions taking effect in 2026; policy breadth alone does not prove practical openness. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. State Department 2026 nationality-specific visa restrictions) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 15 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
The LuvYou Care-Port and distributed-nuclei work treats visitors, migrants, learners and refugees as people who should retain practical access to movement, family care and ordinary participation.
Refugee Processing Center data record 12,904 refugee arrivals during FY2026 through August 31. The figure is partial-year and sits beside the separate 39-country visa/entry restrictions already recorded.
The Department of State states that a January 2026 pause of immigrant visa issuance to nationals of 75 countries was no longer in effect as of August 21, 2026 following a court order. This separate pause is therefore not counted as a current restriction in the America baseline.
US State Department confirms full or partial suspensions affecting 39 countries from January 2026, with limited exceptions and altered family-visa routes; these current restrictions lower verified welcome reach.
The Department of State states that Presidential Proclamation 10998, effective January 1, 2026, fully or partially suspended entry and visa issuance for nationals of 39 countries and for people applying with Palestinian Authority travel documents, subject to limited exceptions.
The Department of State reported that the United States resettled 100,000 refugees in fiscal year 2024. Current FY2026 reporting is retained separately because the policy environment changed after 2024.
Afghan and Iraqi SIV arrivals receiving resettlement benefits, FY2026 through August 31: 2645.00000000
USRAP refugee arrivals, FY2026 through August 31: 12904.00000000
August 31, 2026
Refugees resettled through USRAP: 100000.00000000
Countries subject to full or partial entry/visa suspension under Proclamation 10998: 39.00000000
Visa Waiver Program maximum stay for eligible visitors: 90.00000000
Human Time & Burden Return changed from -22.5 to -3.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -22.50 | -3.75 |
| Base category score | -22.50 | -3.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 55.00 | 50.00 |
| Reach (35%) | -40.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -65.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Regeneration (15%) | -40.00 | -25.00 |
Category point adjustment: +18.75 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 01 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
America has major productive capacity, but this category measures whether that capacity returns usable family time. In 2025 full-time workers averaged 8.07 hours on days worked and 29.6% worked on an average weekend day; only 27% of civilian workers had access to paid family leave in the latest comparable BLS series, and there is still no federal guarantee of paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers. BLS consumer-expenditure data also show housing and transportation absorbing 50.4% of average spending in 2024. Under the TBF family-time standard, capacity therefore no longer outweighs the reach and friction burden.
Sources archived before (9)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Full-time work on days worked. BLS 2025 ATUS annual average for full-time workers on days worked; table 4 reports 8.07 hours (rounded to 8.1 hours in the release text).. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
BLS May 2026 data show 5.2% of employed people held multiple jobs; some household pressure is missed if surveys use jobs as the denominator.
The U.S. Department of Labor states that while many workers may qualify for unpaid FMLA leave and some workers receive paid benefits through employers or state programs, there is currently no federal law guaranteeing paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
Housing and transportation share of household spending: 50.40000000
Civilian workers with access to paid family leave: 27.00000000
Full-time workers working on an average weekend day: 29.60000000
Full-time work on days worked: 8.07000000
Sources archived after the change (17)
United States, category 01, rail 4: -25/100. Remote-work availability and household technologies can free time for some, but national proof of Shubaka-style shared family contribution and universal restoration is absent. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 4: -25/100. Remote-work availability and household technologies can free time for some, but national proof of Shubaka-style shared family contribution and universal restoration is absent. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 3: -50/100. BLS unpaid care and household activity measures show continuing family labor alongside paid work; score reflects the remaining structural time burden, not a nationally counted “forced hours” rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 3: -50/100. BLS unpaid care and household activity measures show continuing family labor alongside paid work; score reflects the remaining structural time burden, not a nationally counted “forced hours” rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 2: +0/100. Some leave protections and family services exist; federal law does not guarantee universal paid parental leave, so the share with sustained family-time relief is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 2: +0/100. Some leave protections and family services exist; federal law does not guarantee universal paid parental leave, so the share with sustained family-time relief is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 1: +50/100. 2025 ATUS documents a mature national time-use data system, wage-work and care schedules; it does not document a comprehensive family-time release infrastructure. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 1: +50/100. 2025 ATUS documents a mature national time-use data system, wage-work and care schedules; it does not document a comprehensive family-time release infrastructure. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Full-time work on days worked. BLS 2025 ATUS annual average for full-time workers on days worked; table 4 reports 8.07 hours (rounded to 8.1 hours in the release text).. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
BLS May 2026 data show 5.2% of employed people held multiple jobs; some household pressure is missed if surveys use jobs as the denominator.
The U.S. Department of Labor states that while many workers may qualify for unpaid FMLA leave and some workers receive paid benefits through employers or state programs, there is currently no federal law guaranteeing paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
Housing and transportation share of household spending: 50.40000000
Civilian workers with access to paid family leave: 27.00000000
Full-time workers working on an average weekend day: 29.60000000
Full-time work on days worked: 8.07000000
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach changed from -30 to -3.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Housing, Shelter & Housing Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -30.00 | -3.75 |
| Base category score | -30.00 | -3.75 |
| Reach (35%) | -65.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -85.00 | -75.00 |
Category point adjustment: +26.25 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 02 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The United States has enormous physical housing capacity and near-universal plumbing, but shelter reach is materially weaker than stock suggests. In 2024, 46.23% of renter households were cost-burdened, median gross rent reached $1,487 and the median renter spent 31% of income on rent and utilities. Homeownership was 65.0% in Q2 2026, while HUD counted 745,652 people homeless on one night in January 2025. GAO finds institutional investors are a real but limited part of the national picture—about 1–3% of all single-family homes in six studied metros in 2024—so the negative score is driven by affordability and reach, not a claim that large investors own most U.S. homes.
Sources archived before (10)
GAO's 2026 study found institutional investors owned about 1% to 3% of all single-family homes in six selected metropolitan areas in 2024, while their share of single-family rental homes ranged from 4% to 22%. This supports treating institutional ownership as a localized affordability factor without claiming that large investors own most U.S. homes.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Housing units. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Homeownership rate: 65.00000000
Median gross rent: 1487.00000000
Occupied housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 99.59000000
People experiencing homelessness on a single night: 745652.00000000
Renter households spending over 30% of income on housing: 46.23000000
Housing units: 146740964.00000000
Sources archived after the change (18)
United States, category 02, rail 4: -25/100. Shelter programs and private maintenance give partial continuity; recurring unaffordable costs and homelessness do not establish secure unconditional family homes. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 4: -25/100. Shelter programs and private maintenance give partial continuity; recurring unaffordable costs and homelessness do not establish secure unconditional family homes. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 3: -75/100. ACS 2024 reports median gross rent $1,487 and median rent-to-income share 31%; housing costs and insecurity remain high structural obstacles. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 3: -75/100. ACS 2024 reports median gross rent $1,487 and median rent-to-income share 31%; housing costs and insecurity remain high structural obstacles. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 2: +0/100. HUD recorded 745,652 people experiencing homelessness in January 2025; ACS documents extensive owner/renter housing but does not establish money-free family shelter reach. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 2: +0/100. HUD recorded 745,652 people experiencing homelessness in January 2025; ACS documents extensive owner/renter housing but does not establish money-free family shelter reach. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 1: +75/100. The United States maintains very large physical housing capacity, documented by ACS household costs and HUD housing/homelessness systems, despite shortages in affordable accommodation. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 02, rail 1: +75/100. The United States maintains very large physical housing capacity, documented by ACS household costs and HUD housing/homelessness systems, despite shortages in affordable accommodation. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (HUD 2025 Annual Homelessness Assessment) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 02 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
GAO's 2026 study found institutional investors owned about 1% to 3% of all single-family homes in six selected metropolitan areas in 2024, while their share of single-family rental homes ranged from 4% to 22%. This supports treating institutional ownership as a localized affordability factor without claiming that large investors own most U.S. homes.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Housing units. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats housing reach as more than physical housing stock: a family should be able to begin and continue life without shelter consuming decades of household earnings or pushing young families into chronic financial pressure.
Homeownership rate: 65.00000000
Median gross rent: 1487.00000000
Occupied housing units with complete plumbing facilities: 99.59000000
People experiencing homelessness on a single night: 745652.00000000
Renter households spending over 30% of income on housing: 46.23000000
Housing units: 146740964.00000000
Health & Care Reach changed from 2.5 to 8.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Health & Care Reach
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 2.50 | 8.75 |
| Base category score | 2.50 | 8.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 90.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 0.00 | 25.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -80.00 | -75.00 |
Category point adjustment: +6.25 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 06 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The United States has deep clinical and medical capacity, and 92.1% of people had health insurance for at least part of 2025. Reach is nevertheless heavily friction-loaded: 7.9% were uninsured for the full year, CMS reports $15,474 in health spending per person and $556.6 billion in out-of-pocket spending in 2024, and maternal mortality remained 17.9 per 100,000 live births. CDC final data show life expectancy improved to 79.0 years in 2024, so the score keeps that positive outcome while sharply reducing the credit given to expensive capacity that does not translate cleanly into household reach.
Sources archived before (10)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population with health insurance for all or part of year. Calculated as the complement of the Census Bureau estimate that 7.9% of people were uninsured for the entire year in 2025.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Life expectancy at birth: 79.00000000
Out-of-pocket health spending: 556.60000000
National health expenditure per person: 15474.00000000
Infant mortality rate: 5.52500000
Maternal mortality rate: 17.90000000
Population uninsured for the full year: 7.90000000
Population with health insurance for all or part of year: 92.10000000
Sources archived after the change (18)
United States, category 06, rail 4: +0/100. Organized preventive and specialist pathways exist, but the linked national insurance figures cannot establish universal continuity or measurable Health Upon Health return. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CMS Federal emergency screening/stabilization rights) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 4: +0/100. Organized preventive and specialist pathways exist, but the linked national insurance figures cannot establish universal continuity or measurable Health Upon Health return. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CMS Federal emergency screening/stabilization rights) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 3: -75/100. Insurance gaps, premiums, co-pays, deductibles and household healthcare spending impose persistent barriers despite real clinical capacity. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 3: -75/100. Insurance gaps, premiums, co-pays, deductibles and household healthcare spending impose persistent barriers despite real clinical capacity. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 2: +25/100. Emergency stabilization and public coverage create meaningful access pathways, but insurance is not proof that necessary medicines, dental or specialist care is free for everyone. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (CMS Federal emergency screening/stabilization rights) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 2: +25/100. Emergency stabilization and public coverage create meaningful access pathways, but insurance is not proof that necessary medicines, dental or specialist care is free for everyone. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (CMS Federal emergency screening/stabilization rights) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 1: +75/100. Specialized hospitals and emergency services operate widely; CDC nonetheless reports that 8.3% of Americans lacked health insurance in 2025. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CMS Federal emergency screening/stabilization rights) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 06, rail 1: +75/100. Specialized hospitals and emergency services operate widely; CDC nonetheless reports that 8.3% of Americans lacked health insurance in 2025. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (CDC 2025 Health Insurance NHIS Estimates) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CMS Federal emergency screening/stabilization rights) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 06 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population with health insurance for all or part of year. Calculated as the complement of the Census Bureau estimate that 7.9% of people were uninsured for the entire year in 2025.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing argues that hospitals, medicines and clinical knowledge should be judged by whether families can actually reach care without financial strain. This authored interpretation is presented beside official insurance, spending and health-outcome data.
Life expectancy at birth: 79.00000000
Out-of-pocket health spending: 556.60000000
National health expenditure per person: 15474.00000000
Infant mortality rate: 5.52500000
Maternal mortality rate: 17.90000000
Population uninsured for the full year: 7.90000000
Population with health insurance for all or part of year: 92.10000000
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance changed from -7.75 to 15. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Food, Nourishment & Free Food Abundance
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -7.75 | 15.00 |
| Base category score | -7.75 | 15.00 |
| Research coverage (%) | 90.00 | 100.00 |
| Capacity (25%) | 90.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | -25.00 | 25.00 |
| Friction / Waste (25%) | -65.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Multiplication (15%) | -35.00 | 0.00 |
Category point adjustment: +22.75 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 03 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
America has extraordinary food-production capacity, but the category asks whether nourishment actually reaches people and whether abundance is multiplied rather than wasted. USDA reports 13.7% of households were food insecure in 2024 and 5.4% experienced very low food security; EPA states that 30–40% of the U.S. food supply is never eaten. Under the TBF standard, strong physical supply therefore no longer outweighs money-gated reach, food insecurity and large loss/waste.
Sources archived before (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
USDA 2024 found 13.7% of US households food-insecure and 5.4% with very low food security; the national free-school-meal route does not cover all family nourishment.
30–40%
Households with very low food security: 5.40000000
Food-insecure households: 13.70000000
Food-secure households: 86.30000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 03, rail 4: +0/100. Food infrastructure and donation/recovery systems exist, but source evidence does not establish widespread regenerative Soil-Crown style circulation; neutral return is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (USDA 2024 household food security report) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 4: +0/100. Food infrastructure and donation/recovery systems exist, but source evidence does not establish widespread regenerative Soil-Crown style circulation; neutral return is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (USDA 2024 household food security report) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 3: -50/100. Household food insecurity is explicitly associated with resource constraints, while routine food requires money; the Friction score is an anchored TBF judgment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (USDA 2024 household food security report) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 3: -50/100. Household food insecurity is explicitly associated with resource constraints, while routine food requires money; the Friction score is an anchored TBF judgment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (USDA 2024 household food security report) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 2: +25/100. School meal benefits and targeted nutrition assistance provide real but institution/eligibility-dependent free nourishment, not universal family food without payment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (USDA National School Lunch Program) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (USDA 2024 household food security report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 2: +25/100. School meal benefits and targeted nutrition assistance provide real but institution/eligibility-dependent free nourishment, not universal family food without payment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (USDA National School Lunch Program) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (USDA 2024 household food security report) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 1: +75/100. USDA found 86.3% of households food secure in 2024, but 13.7% experienced food insecurity and 5.4% very low food security; substantial food supply exists. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (USDA 2024 household food security report) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (USDA National School Lunch Program) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 03, rail 1: +75/100. USDA found 86.3% of households food secure in 2024, but 13.7% experienced food insecurity and 5.4% very low food security; substantial food supply exists. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (USDA 2024 household food security report) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (USDA National School Lunch Program) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 03 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization writing treats food abundance as a reach question: physical food can exist in great quantity while families still face price gates, food insecurity and little direct access to living food systems. This is an authored interpretive standard and is stored separately from official statistics.
USDA 2024 found 13.7% of US households food-insecure and 5.4% with very low food security; the national free-school-meal route does not cover all family nourishment.
30–40%
Households with very low food security: 5.40000000
Food-insecure households: 13.70000000
Food-secure households: 86.30000000
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability changed from -76.25 to -60. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Family Formation, Continuity & Child Stability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -76.25 | -60.00 |
| Base category score | -26.25 | -10.00 |
| Capacity (25%) | 45.00 | 50.00 |
| Reach (35%) | -35.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -70.00 | -75.00 |
| Return / Continuity (15%) | -50.00 | -25.00 |
Category point adjustment: +16.25 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 09 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted. Existing TFR 60/40 blend and separate marriage-law policy treatment preserved; provisional 2025 births are NOT total fertility rate.
Earlier reasoning
Family households remain common and most family households are married-couple households, which is positive evidence. The continuity picture is nevertheless materially strained under the TBF family-centered standard: one-person households are 29%, fertility is at a record low, paid-family-leave reach is incomplete, and 39.5% of 2024 births were to unmarried women. These indicators do not prove the quality of any individual household; they are used as national family-formation and continuity signals alongside the Trott Bailey Family authored standard.
Sources archived before (9)
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Households classified as family households. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
Births to unmarried women: 39.50000000
Total fertility rate: 1599.50000000
All households that are one-person households: 29.00000000
Family households that are married-couple households: 74.00000000
Households classified as family households: 64.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
Sources archived after the change (17)
United States, category 09, rail 4: -25/100. CDC 2025 provisional births were down 1% from 2024; the 5.0 TBF fertility target is a separate value anchor, not an established necessary population outcome. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (CDC 2025 provisional births) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census Families and Living Arrangements) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 4: -25/100. CDC 2025 provisional births were down 1% from 2024; the 5.0 TBF fertility target is a separate value anchor, not an established necessary population outcome. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (CDC 2025 provisional births) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census Families and Living Arrangements) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 3: -75/100. Housing prices, childcare time and paid-leave limits burden family formation; the TBF friction score is interpretive, not an official causal effect on births. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 3: -75/100. Housing prices, childcare time and paid-leave limits burden family formation; the TBF friction score is interpretive, not an official causal effect on births. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 2: +0/100. Marriage, parenting, shelter and childcare remain materially available to many, but free stable lifelong family support across the whole population is not demonstrated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census Families and Living Arrangements) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 2: +0/100. Marriage, parenting, shelter and childcare remain materially available to many, but free stable lifelong family support across the whole population is not demonstrated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census Families and Living Arrangements) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census ACS 2024 owner and renter housing costs) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 1: +50/100. Family households, public birth/childcare services and clinical maternity capacity exist; nationwide automatic home/land provision upon marriage does not. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census Families and Living Arrangements) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CDC 2025 provisional births) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 09, rail 1: +50/100. Family households, public birth/childcare services and clinical maternity capacity exist; nationwide automatic home/land provision upon marriage does not. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Census Families and Living Arrangements) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (CDC 2025 provisional births) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 09 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Households classified as family households. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
The Trott Bailey Family explicitly treats stable marriage, parental presence and child continuity as core civilization infrastructure. The America family reading therefore considers measured marriage, household, birth and leave conditions through that declared family-centered standard.
Births to unmarried women: 39.50000000
Total fertility rate: 1599.50000000
All households that are one-person households: 29.00000000
Family households that are married-couple households: 74.00000000
Households classified as family households: 64.00000000
The country-specific national legislation or court record corroborates legal recognition of same-sex marriage. The score adjustment is an authored TBF policy judgment, not a causal fertility estimate.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct changed from 0.5 to 5. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
External Footprint & Non-Extractive Global Conduct
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 0.50 | 5.00 |
| Base category score | 0.50 | 5.00 |
| Research coverage (%) | 84.00 | 100.00 |
| Positive Contribution (25%) | 65.00 | 50.00 |
| Mutuality / Local Benefit (25%) | 15.00 | 25.00 |
| Documented Harm / Extraction (35%) | -45.00 | -50.00 |
| Accountability / Repair (15%) | -25.00 | -12.50 |
Category point adjustment: +4.50 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 16 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted. 3.1 weights 25/25/20/30; rail 4 composite of exporter -25 and importer 0, counted exactly once. Old readings untouched in history. Stored category base score explicitly 5.0 under method 3.1, rather than global older 25/25/35/15 default.
Earlier reasoning
OECD identifies USD 29bn in 2025 ODA, a substantial absolute outward contribution, but 2025 aid contracted 56.9% in real terms. Broader consumption emissions and external harms warrant negative scrutiny, while local mutuality and repair are insufficiently demonstrated. These four rails are a transparent TBF qualitative judgment, not a causal estimate of specific international harms.
Sources archived before (12)
The Distributed Founding Nuclei strategy treats external expansion as successful when it transfers useful capability, supports local roots and avoids organizing other people around extraction.
OECD reports preliminary 2025 US ODA of USD 29 billion (0.09% of GNI), down 56.9% in real terms compared with 2024; positive provision remains material but fell sharply. The evidence alone does not establish downstream local benefit or all cross-border impacts.
OECD preliminary data report USD 29 billion of U.S. official development assistance in 2025, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% in real terms from 2024. This is retained as measurable contribution evidence without turning foreign-policy choices into a TBF numeric verdict.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
OECD reports U.S. ODA at 0.23% of GNI in 2024 and preliminary 2025 ODA of USD 29.0 billion, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% from 2024. The release stores the measurable contribution without converting it into an overall external-conduct judgment.
Real-terms change in official development assistance: -56.90000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI, preliminary: 0.09000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions per capita: 15.80000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions: 5.43000000
Official development assistance, preliminary: 29.00000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI: 0.23000000
Sources archived after the change (20)
United States, category 16, rail 4: -12.5/100. WITS/UN Comtrade reports $264.3m of US plastic-scrap exports and $385.7m imports in 2024; exporter role −25, importer role 0 produce −12.5 average. Lawful trade is not proof of dumping. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Exports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Imports) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -12.5/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 4: -12.5/100. WITS/UN Comtrade reports $264.3m of US plastic-scrap exports and $385.7m imports in 2024; exporter role −25, importer role 0 produce −12.5 average. Lawful trade is not proof of dumping. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Exports) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (World Bank WITS 2024 US Plastic Scrap Imports) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -12.5/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 3: -50/100. Large global emissions and international policy effects can impose costs outside the US; specific causal attribution and repair outcomes need recipient-level investigation. −50 is an explicit TBF proxy judgment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 3: -50/100. Large global emissions and international policy effects can impose costs outside the US; specific causal attribution and repair outcomes need recipient-level investigation. −50 is an explicit TBF proxy judgment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 2: +25/100. ODA can support health, development and infrastructure abroad, while recipient control and durable long-term benefit are not established by donor spending totals alone. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 2: +25/100. ODA can support health, development and infrastructure abroad, while recipient control and durable long-term benefit are not established by donor spending totals alone. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (OECD International Migration Outlook 2025, United States) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 1: +50/100. OECD reports $29bn U.S. ODA in preliminary 2025, down 56.9% year-on-year. Significant direct contributions remain but continuity has weakened. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 16, rail 1: +50/100. OECD reports $29bn U.S. ODA in preliminary 2025, down 56.9% year-on-year. Significant direct contributions remain but continuity has weakened. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (OECD U.S. Development Cooperation 2026 Country Profile) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (Global Carbon Budget consumption-based carbon emissions) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 16 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
The Distributed Founding Nuclei strategy treats external expansion as successful when it transfers useful capability, supports local roots and avoids organizing other people around extraction.
OECD reports preliminary 2025 US ODA of USD 29 billion (0.09% of GNI), down 56.9% in real terms compared with 2024; positive provision remains material but fell sharply. The evidence alone does not establish downstream local benefit or all cross-border impacts.
OECD preliminary data report USD 29 billion of U.S. official development assistance in 2025, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% in real terms from 2024. This is retained as measurable contribution evidence without turning foreign-policy choices into a TBF numeric verdict.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
Global Carbon Budget data presented by Our World in Data estimate U.S. consumption-based CO2 emissions at 5.43 billion tonnes in 2023, or 15.8 tonnes per person. This measure assigns production emissions to final consumption through trade adjustment.
OECD reports U.S. ODA at 0.23% of GNI in 2024 and preliminary 2025 ODA of USD 29.0 billion, equal to 0.09% of GNI and down 56.9% from 2024. The release stores the measurable contribution without converting it into an overall external-conduct judgment.
Real-terms change in official development assistance: -56.90000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI, preliminary: 0.09000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions per capita: 15.80000000
Consumption-based CO2 emissions: 5.43000000
Official development assistance, preliminary: 29.00000000
Official development assistance as share of GNI: 0.23000000
Energy & Household Capability changed from 12 to 33.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Energy & Household Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 12.00 | 33.75 |
| Base category score | 12.00 | 33.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 95.00 | 100.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 20.00 | 50.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -60.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Burden Removed (15%) | -25.00 | 25.00 |
Category point adjustment: +21.75 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 05 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The United States has exceptional energy capacity, but household reach and burden return are weaker than production totals suggest. EIA reports 13.4 million residential electricity disconnections for bill nonpayment in 2024, while fossil fuels still supplied about 58% of utility-scale electricity generation in 2025 and renewables were only about 9% of total U.S. energy consumption. The TBF standard therefore separates national production from dependable household capability.
Sources archived before (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization evaluates energy by what it lets households do—cool, cook, pump water, preserve food, move and remove strain—rather than by production totals alone.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Primary energy production. EIA reported 106.96 quadrillion Btu of total U.S. energy production in 2025; the accompanying article rounds this to 107 quads.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Residential electricity disconnections for bill nonpayment: 13.40000000
Utility-scale electricity generated from fossil fuels: 58.00000000
Average electricity interruption duration per customer: 11.00000000
Renewable energy consumption: 8.83000000
Primary energy production: 106.96000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 05, rail 4: +25/100. Energy-powered household machinery and refrigeration return real useful capability; the +25 recognizes them without claiming universal free provision or full climate resilience. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 4: +25/100. Energy-powered household machinery and refrigeration return real useful capability; the +25 recognizes them without claiming universal free provision or full climate resilience. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 3: -50/100. EIA reports the average 2025 residential electricity retail price was 17.30¢/kWh; bills, energy insecurity and failures continue. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 3: -50/100. EIA reports the average 2025 residential electricity retail price was 17.30¢/kWh; bills, energy insecurity and failures continue. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 2: +50/100. Electric service is broadly usable but money-free, reliable access to both electricity and safe cooking for the entire population is not established; Reach is an approximate TBF assessment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 2: +50/100. Electric service is broadly usable but money-free, reliable access to both electricity and safe cooking for the entire population is not established; Reach is an approximate TBF assessment. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Census 2025 Income/Poverty/Insurance Release) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 1: +100/100. The U.S. operates extensive electricity generation, grids and household equipment capable of supporting cooking, cooling and productive work. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +100/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 05, rail 1: +100/100. The U.S. operates extensive electricity generation, grids and household equipment capable of supporting cooking, cooling and productive work. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (EIA U.S. 2025 residential electricity prices) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 05 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +100/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization evaluates energy by what it lets households do—cool, cook, pump water, preserve food, move and remove strain—rather than by production totals alone.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Primary energy production. EIA reported 106.96 quadrillion Btu of total U.S. energy production in 2025; the accompanying article rounds this to 107 quads.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Residential electricity disconnections for bill nonpayment: 13.40000000
Utility-scale electricity generated from fossil fuels: 58.00000000
Average electricity interruption duration per customer: 11.00000000
Renewable energy consumption: 8.83000000
Primary energy production: 106.96000000
Education & Human Capability changed from 12 to 23.75. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Education & Human Capability
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 12.00 | 23.75 |
| Base category score | 12.00 | 23.75 |
| Capacity (25%) | 90.00 | 75.00 |
| Reach (35%) | 25.00 | 50.00 |
| Friction (25%) | -65.00 | -50.00 |
| Return / Capability (15%) | -20.00 | 0.00 |
Category point adjustment: +11.75 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 07 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
Formal educational reach and adult attainment are broad, but foundational outcomes materially weaken the capability reading. In 2024 only 31% of fourth-graders were at or above NAEP Proficient in reading, 40% were below NAEP Basic, and only 28% of eighth-graders were at or above NAEP Proficient in mathematics. Under the NoDumbDumbs capability standard, institutional capacity cannot outweigh weak demonstrated foundational mastery.
Sources archived before (7)
NoDumbDumbs treats education as demonstrated understanding and capability, not years of institutional attendance alone; national attainment is therefore read beside foundational learning outcomes.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population age 25+ with high school education or higher. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Eighth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in mathematics: 28.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Basic in reading: 60.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in reading: 31.00000000
Population age 25+ with bachelor degree or higher: 36.80000000
Population age 25+ with high school education or higher: 89.90000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 07, rail 4: +0/100. Strong learning and research capability coexist with uneven proficiency and limited direct nationwide measurement of applied lifelong NoDumbDumbs capability; neutral Return inferred. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (NCES NAEP 2024 mathematics outcomes) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 4: +0/100. Strong learning and research capability coexist with uneven proficiency and limited direct nationwide measurement of applied lifelong NoDumbDumbs capability; neutral Return inferred. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (NCES NAEP 2024 mathematics outcomes) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 3: -50/100. Households spend money on education; uneven outcomes and learning supports imply continuing access, material and time burdens. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS Consumer Expenditures: education expenses) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 3: -50/100. Households spend money on education; uneven outcomes and learning supports imply continuing access, material and time burdens. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS Consumer Expenditures: education expenses) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 2: +50/100. 2024 NAEP found 31% of fourth graders at or above NAEP Proficient in reading and 39% in mathematics; enrollment does not certify full competence or adult lifelong learning. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 mathematics outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 2: +50/100. 2024 NAEP found 31% of fourth graders at or above NAEP Proficient in reading and 39% in mathematics; enrollment does not certify full competence or adult lifelong learning. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 mathematics outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 1: +75/100. The United States operates broad schools, colleges and practical learning institutions, with a national assessment system evaluating core skills. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (NCES NAEP 2024 mathematics outcomes) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 07, rail 1: +75/100. The United States operates broad schools, colleges and practical learning institutions, with a national assessment system evaluating core skills. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (NCES NAEP 2024 mathematics outcomes) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (NCES NAEP 2024 reading outcomes) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 07 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
NoDumbDumbs treats education as demonstrated understanding and capability, not years of institutional attendance alone; national attainment is therefore read beside foundational learning outcomes.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Population age 25+ with high school education or higher. . Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Eighth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in mathematics: 28.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Basic in reading: 60.00000000
Fourth-grade students at or above NAEP Proficient in reading: 31.00000000
Population age 25+ with bachelor degree or higher: 36.80000000
Population age 25+ with high school education or higher: 89.90000000
Durability, Repair & Material Return changed from -7.25 to -10. Review the recorded rails, explanation and source records below.
Durability, Repair & Material Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -7.25 | -10.00 |
| Base category score | -7.25 | -10.00 |
| Research coverage (%) | 90.00 | 100.00 |
| Capacity (25%) | 70.00 | 50.00 |
| Reach (35%) | -10.00 | 0.00 |
| Friction / Waste (25%) | -70.00 | -75.00 |
Category point adjustment: -2.75 category points
Updated reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 14 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Earlier reasoning
The United States has major manufacturing, maintenance and recycling capacity, but national material-return evidence remains weak and dated. EPA’s latest national municipal-waste series reports 292.4 million tons of waste, 4.9 pounds per person per day, a 32.1% recycling/composting rate and only about 9% plastics recycling in 2018. FTC repair findings document multiple forms of repair restriction. The score therefore treats high material throughput and repair friction as substantial losses while keeping coverage at 90% because the national waste series is stale.
Sources archived before (7)
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats repair, maintenance, local skill and material return as civilization capability; high throughput is a burden when useful goods repeatedly become waste.
The Federal Trade Commission identified restrictions including limited spare-parts availability, inaccessible diagnostic software and product designs that make repair more difficult, while finding scant evidence for many manufacturer justifications.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Municipal solid waste generated. EPA national materials series is current through 2018; retained with reduced confidence rather than treated as current-year data.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Plastics recycling rate in municipal solid waste: 9.00000000
Municipal solid waste recycling and composting rate: 32.10000000
Municipal solid waste generated per person: 4.90000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 292.40000000
Sources archived after the change (15)
United States, category 14, rail 4: -25/100. Reuse and recycling offer partial benefits, but national proof of long-lasting repairable products and safe material recirculation remains insufficient. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 4: -25/100. Reuse and recycling offer partial benefits, but national proof of long-lasting repairable products and safe material recirculation remains insufficient. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 3: -75/100. FTC documented anti-competitive repair restrictions; EPA 2018 recycling/composting rate was 32.1%, with significant landfilled waste. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 3: -75/100. FTC documented anti-competitive repair restrictions; EPA 2018 recycling/composting rate was 32.1%, with significant landfilled waste. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -75/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 2: +0/100. Nationwide money-free repair reach is not measured; many parts, diagnostics and skilled labor require payment, so universal access is not established. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 2: +0/100. Nationwide money-free repair reach is not measured; many parts, diagnostics and skilled labor require payment, so universal access is not established. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 1: +50/100. Product repair businesses, waste collection and remanufacturing exist; FTC documents repair-access restrictions that limit usable capacity. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 14, rail 1: +50/100. Product repair businesses, waste collection and remanufacturing exist; FTC documents repair-access restrictions that limit usable capacity. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (FTC repair restrictions report 2021) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (EPA US Materials Recycling, 2018 baseline) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 14 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Trott Bailey Family Civilization treats repair, maintenance, local skill and material return as civilization capability; high throughput is a burden when useful goods repeatedly become waste.
The Federal Trade Commission identified restrictions including limited spare-parts availability, inaccessible diagnostic software and product designs that make repair more difficult, while finding scant evidence for many manufacturer justifications.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Municipal solid waste generated. EPA national materials series is current through 2018; retained with reduced confidence rather than treated as current-year data.. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
Plastics recycling rate in municipal solid waste: 9.00000000
Municipal solid waste recycling and composting rate: 32.10000000
Municipal solid waste generated per person: 4.90000000
Municipal solid waste generated: 292.40000000
The headline TBF Abundance Score changed after the underlying published country dataset changed.
Earlier score events did not preserve an exact category-by-category diff. Review detailed category change events recorded after the new history audit was activated.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #208 to #201 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Countries that fell below this country (7)
- Jamaica #201 → #202; points -72.81 → -72.81
- Mozambique #202 → #203; points -72.82 → -72.82
- Burkina Faso #203 → #204; points -73.07 → -73.07
- Western Sahara #204 → #205; points -73.29 → -73.29
- Egypt #205 → #206; points -73.57 → -73.57
- Marshall Islands #206 → #207; points -73.68 → -73.68
- Zimbabwe #207 → #208; points -74.56 → -74.56
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #201 to #200 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Nigeria #185 → #214; points -70.60 → -78.63
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #200 to #199 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Puerto Rico #144 → #206; points -65.87 → -74.42
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #199 to #198 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- The Bahamas #196 → #241
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 19:30 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #198 to #197 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- China #172 → #240
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 19:30 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #197 to #196 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Japan #105 → #240
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 19:30 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #196 to #195 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- South Korea #116 → #240
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 19:30 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #195 to #194 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Russia #147 → #239
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #194 to #193 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Mongolia #129 → #238; points -64.72 → -64.72
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #193 to #192 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Benin #151 → #235; points -67.23 → -67.23
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #192 to #191 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Kyrgyzstan #131 → #236
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 19:30 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #191 to #190 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Botswana #113 → #231; points -62.99 → -62.99
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 18 Oct 2026 · 19:30 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #190 to #189 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Moldova #103 → #236; points -61.81 → -61.81
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #189 to #188 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- North Macedonia #86 → #238; points -59.97 → -59.97
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #188 to #187 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Madagascar #185 → #234; points -72.13 → -72.13
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #187 to #186 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Italy #34 → #230
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #186 to #185 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Tajikistan #169 → #240
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 19 Oct 2026 · 11:19 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #186 to #184 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- Laos #133 → #232; points -65.76 → -65.76
- Tajikistan #169 → #240
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #184 to #183 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Malawi #182 → #233
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 19 Oct 2026 · 11:19 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #183 to #182 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Rwanda #113 → #238; points -63.72 → -63.72
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #182 to #181 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Namibia #124 → #234
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #181 to #180 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Mauritius #74 → #231
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #180 to #179 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Brunei #15 → #220; points -50.29 → -50.29
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 19 Oct 2026 · 11:19 GMT-0500; 4 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #179 to #178 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Mauritania #159 → #229
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #178 to #177 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Tokelau #2 → #241
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #177 to #176 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- San Marino #3 → #236
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #178 to #176 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- San Marino #4 → #236; points -47.91 → -47.91
- Tokelau #2 → #241
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #176 to #175 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Falkland Islands #3 → #217
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #175 to #174 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Liechtenstein #3 → #223; points -48.73 → -48.73
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #174 to #173 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Saint Pierre and Miquelon #6 → #235
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #173 to #172 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Kosovo #163 → #219
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #172 to #171 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Togo #148 → #240; points -68.40 → -68.40
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #171 to #170 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Montenegro #48 → #227; points -57.74 → -57.74
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #170 to #169 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Barbados #62 → #206
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #169 to #168 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Sierra Leone #163 → #235; points -71.47 → -71.47
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #168 to #167 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Burundi #163 → #208; points -71.64 → -71.64
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #167 to #166 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Maldives #44 → #221
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #166 to #165 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Fiji #85 → #209
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #165 to #164 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Suriname #89 → #236
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #164 to #163 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Eswatini #133 → #205; points -67.32 → -67.32
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #163 to #162 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Liberia #160 → #214
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #162 to #161 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Andorra #9 → #196; points -49.97 → -49.97
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #163 to #161 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #161 to #160 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Aruba #130 → #195
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #160 to #159 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Bhutan #70 → #197; points -59.75 → -59.75
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
Held through 20 Oct 2026 · 08:33 GMT-0500; 2 identical observations condensed for display, all source records retained.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #159 to #158 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Belize #84 → #194
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #158 to #157 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Serbia #52 → #231
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #158 to #156 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- Guinea-Bissau #157 → #206; points -72.72 → -72.72
- Serbia #52 → #231
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #157 to #156 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Guinea-Bissau #156 → #206
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #155 to #154 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Slovenia #64 → #232
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #156 to #155 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Latvia #52 → #212
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #156 to #153 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (3)
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #154 to #153 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Georgia #95 → #203
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #152 to #151 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Cambodia #119 → #194
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #153 to #152 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Armenia #79 → #186
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #150 to #149 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Lithuania #49 → #213
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #151 to #150 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Guyana #72 → #204
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #149 to #148 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Senegal #113 → #229
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #148 to #169 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (21)
- Mauritius First recorded here at #63; earlier position unavailable
- Bhutan First recorded here at #67; earlier position unavailable
- Guyana First recorded here at #71; earlier position unavailable
- Japan First recorded here at #77; earlier position unavailable
- Fiji First recorded here at #79; earlier position unavailable
- Belize First recorded here at #83; earlier position unavailable
- Suriname First recorded here at #85; earlier position unavailable
- Moldova First recorded here at #90; earlier position unavailable
- Rwanda First recorded here at #97; earlier position unavailable
- Georgia First recorded here at #105; earlier position unavailable
- Botswana First recorded here at #106; earlier position unavailable
- Mongolia First recorded here at #116; earlier position unavailable
- Namibia First recorded here at #117; earlier position unavailable
- Senegal First recorded here at #127; earlier position unavailable
- Laos First recorded here at #128; earlier position unavailable
- Eswatini First recorded here at #134; earlier position unavailable
- Benin First recorded here at #137; earlier position unavailable
- China First recorded here at #143; earlier position unavailable
- Mauritania First recorded here at #150; earlier position unavailable
- Sierra Leone First recorded here at #166; earlier position unavailable
- Liberia First recorded here at #168; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #169 to #186 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (17)
- Lithuania First recorded here at #46; earlier position unavailable
- Montenegro First recorded here at #47; earlier position unavailable
- South Korea First recorded here at #48; earlier position unavailable
- Latvia First recorded here at #54; earlier position unavailable
- Barbados First recorded here at #57; earlier position unavailable
- Slovenia First recorded here at #68; earlier position unavailable
- Serbia First recorded here at #73; earlier position unavailable
- Armenia First recorded here at #86; earlier position unavailable
- North Macedonia First recorded here at #90; earlier position unavailable
- Kyrgyzstan First recorded here at #128; earlier position unavailable
- Cambodia First recorded here at #141; earlier position unavailable
- Aruba First recorded here at #145; earlier position unavailable
- Togo First recorded here at #156; earlier position unavailable
- Kosovo First recorded here at #173; earlier position unavailable
- Burundi First recorded here at #178; earlier position unavailable
- The Bahamas First recorded here at #183; earlier position unavailable
- Jamaica First recorded here at #184; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #186 to #197 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (11)
- Tokelau First recorded here at #2; earlier position unavailable
- San Marino First recorded here at #4; earlier position unavailable
- Falkland Islands First recorded here at #5; earlier position unavailable
- Liechtenstein First recorded here at #6; earlier position unavailable
- Saint Pierre and Miquelon First recorded here at #10; earlier position unavailable
- Andorra First recorded here at #14; earlier position unavailable
- Brunei First recorded here at #15; earlier position unavailable
- Italy First recorded here at #36; earlier position unavailable
- Maldives First recorded here at #51; earlier position unavailable
- Russia First recorded here at #75; earlier position unavailable
- Tajikistan First recorded here at #180; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #186 to #189 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (3)
- San Marino First recorded here at #3; earlier position unavailable
- Liechtenstein First recorded here at #4; earlier position unavailable
- Brunei First recorded here at #11; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #197 to #198 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (1)
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #198 to #199 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer crossing can be confirmed from the two archived ranking snapshots.
Recorded rank movement.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Peer identities were not stored for this older rank event; missing before/after rankings cannot be reconstructed.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #199 to #200 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that moved ahead of this country (1)
- Marshall Islands #207 → #179; points -73.68 → -69.35
Every recorded change
Each archived event is preserved. Category details and sources begin from the first detailed country snapshot; older records remain visible without invented comparisons.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #199 to #200 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that moved ahead of this country (1)
- Marshall Islands #207 → #179; points -73.68 → -69.35
Human Time & Burden Return supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Human Time & Burden Return
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | -3.75 | -3.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
Recorded reasoning
USA 2026-10-18 comprehensive reassessment using published 36-anchor methodology 01 and 4 separately reasoned rails, all 4 scored; data coverage 100% means scoring completion ONLY. Fact/score separation and two sources per rail in evidence. 5 Direct Money Gates unchanged at 1.75/20. Appeal accepted.
Sources archived before (17)
United States, category 01, rail 4: -25/100. Remote-work availability and household technologies can free time for some, but national proof of Shubaka-style shared family contribution and universal restoration is absent. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 4: -25/100. Remote-work availability and household technologies can free time for some, but national proof of Shubaka-style shared family contribution and universal restoration is absent. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 3: -50/100. BLS unpaid care and household activity measures show continuing family labor alongside paid work; score reflects the remaining structural time burden, not a nationally counted “forced hours” rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 3: -50/100. BLS unpaid care and household activity measures show continuing family labor alongside paid work; score reflects the remaining structural time burden, not a nationally counted “forced hours” rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 2: +0/100. Some leave protections and family services exist; federal law does not guarantee universal paid parental leave, so the share with sustained family-time relief is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 2: +0/100. Some leave protections and family services exist; federal law does not guarantee universal paid parental leave, so the share with sustained family-time relief is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 1: +50/100. 2025 ATUS documents a mature national time-use data system, wage-work and care schedules; it does not document a comprehensive family-time release infrastructure. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 1: +50/100. 2025 ATUS documents a mature national time-use data system, wage-work and care schedules; it does not document a comprehensive family-time release infrastructure. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Full-time work on days worked. BLS 2025 ATUS annual average for full-time workers on days worked; table 4 reports 8.07 hours (rounded to 8.1 hours in the release text).. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
BLS May 2026 data show 5.2% of employed people held multiple jobs; some household pressure is missed if surveys use jobs as the denominator.
The U.S. Department of Labor states that while many workers may qualify for unpaid FMLA leave and some workers receive paid benefits through employers or state programs, there is currently no federal law guaranteeing paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
Housing and transportation share of household spending: 50.40000000
Civilian workers with access to paid family leave: 27.00000000
Full-time workers working on an average weekend day: 29.60000000
Full-time work on days worked: 8.07000000
Sources archived after the change (18)
United States, category 01, rail 4: -25/100. Remote-work availability and household technologies can free time for some, but national proof of Shubaka-style shared family contribution and universal restoration is absent. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 4: -25/100. Remote-work availability and household technologies can free time for some, but national proof of Shubaka-style shared family contribution and universal restoration is absent. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -25/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 3: -50/100. BLS unpaid care and household activity measures show continuing family labor alongside paid work; score reflects the remaining structural time burden, not a nationally counted “forced hours” rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 3: -50/100. BLS unpaid care and household activity measures show continuing family labor alongside paid work; score reflects the remaining structural time burden, not a nationally counted “forced hours” rate. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2024 Consumer Expenditure Survey) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score -50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 2: +0/100. Some leave protections and family services exist; federal law does not guarantee universal paid parental leave, so the share with sustained family-time relief is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 2: +0/100. Some leave protections and family services exist; federal law does not guarantee universal paid parental leave, so the share with sustained family-time relief is extrapolated. ASSESSMENT BASIS: EXTRAPOLATED. Document A (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (BLS 2025 detailed household, childcare and work-time tables) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +0/100. This is a transparent interpretive extrapolated judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 1: +50/100. 2025 ATUS documents a mature national time-use data system, wage-work and care schedules; it does not document a comprehensive family-time release infrastructure. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
United States, category 01, rail 1: +50/100. 2025 ATUS documents a mature national time-use data system, wage-work and care schedules; it does not document a comprehensive family-time release infrastructure. ASSESSMENT BASIS: PROXY-SUPPORTED. Document A (BLS 2025 American Time Use Survey) establishes one measured or legally documented part of the U.S. condition. Document B (U.S. Department of Labor Paid Leave overview) provides an independent contextual cross-check or constraint. Comparing these documented facts to the published Category 01 nine-anchor ladder yields TBF rail score +50/100. This is a transparent interpretive proxy-supported judgment, NOT a measured nationwide percent receiving service. Unmeasured full-service and money-free population denominators have not been invented.
The 2025 U.S. American Time Use Survey reports 81% of people did household activities on an average day, spending approximately 2 hours. This describes time use, not availability of free household services.
Verified prior national indicator carried forward without inventing a new reading: Full-time work on days worked. BLS 2025 ATUS annual average for full-time workers on days worked; table 4 reports 8.07 hours (rounded to 8.1 hours in the release text).. Current four-rail score retained pending evidence for a justified numerical revision.
BLS May 2026 data show 5.2% of employed people held multiple jobs; some household pressure is missed if surveys use jobs as the denominator.
The U.S. Department of Labor states that while many workers may qualify for unpaid FMLA leave and some workers receive paid benefits through employers or state programs, there is currently no federal law guaranteeing paid family and medical leave for private-sector workers.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
In its published civilization writing, the Trott Bailey Family argues that rent, food, transport, debt and other priced necessities can force parents to trade family time for earning time; this is stored as an attributed authored interpretation alongside the national time-use and expenditure data.
Housing and transportation share of household spending: 50.40000000
Civilian workers with access to paid family leave: 27.00000000
Full-time workers working on an average weekend day: 29.60000000
Full-time work on days worked: 8.07000000
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate) supporting evidence, citations, notes or rails changed without changing the category total.
Money Gate (separate 20-point gate)
| Category field | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Published category score | 1.75 | 1.75 |
Category point adjustment: 0.00 category points
The evidence explanation changed; the category score stayed the same.
Updated reasoning
- Food
- National School Lunch Program provides eligible free school meals; routine household food is purchased. Institutional school food is limited to the TBF 0.5/4 allowance.
- Healthcare
- EMTALA mandates emergency screening and stabilization without prior payment. Medicaid and other targeted coverage exist, but services may be billed and routine universal no-pay care is absent.
- Housing / Land
- HUD housing vouchers are subsidized rent; families ordinarily pay about 30% of adjusted income. This is not universal free housing or free land.
- Transport
- Regular local and intercity travel is generally fare-based. No nationwide ordinary zero-fare baseline documented.
- Water / Energy
- Targeted assistance or moratoria may protect some households; EIA reports residential disconnections for bill nonpayment. No nationwide no-pay utility continuity.
Earlier reasoning
- Food
- National School Lunch Program provides eligible free school meals; routine household food is purchased. Institutional school food is limited to the TBF 0.5/4 allowance.
- Housing / Land
- HUD housing vouchers are subsidized rent; families ordinarily pay about 30% of adjusted income. This is not universal free housing or free land.
- Healthcare
- EMTALA mandates emergency screening and stabilization without prior payment. Medicaid and other targeted coverage exist, but services may be billed and routine universal no-pay care is absent.
- Transport
- Regular local and intercity travel is generally fare-based. No nationwide ordinary zero-fare baseline documented.
- Water / Energy
- Targeted assistance or moratoria may protect some households; EIA reports residential disconnections for bill nonpayment. No nationwide no-pay utility continuity.
Sources archived before (5)
Sources archived after the change (5)
Published evidence, observations or country data changed. The headline score did not materially change in this update.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #198 to #199 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
No peer crossing can be confirmed from the two archived ranking snapshots.
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #197 to #198 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (1)
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #186 to #197 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (11)
- Tokelau First recorded here at #2; earlier position unavailable
- San Marino First recorded here at #4; earlier position unavailable
- Falkland Islands First recorded here at #5; earlier position unavailable
- Liechtenstein First recorded here at #6; earlier position unavailable
- Saint Pierre and Miquelon First recorded here at #10; earlier position unavailable
- Andorra First recorded here at #14; earlier position unavailable
- Brunei First recorded here at #15; earlier position unavailable
- Italy First recorded here at #36; earlier position unavailable
- Maldives First recorded here at #51; earlier position unavailable
- Russia First recorded here at #75; earlier position unavailable
- Tajikistan First recorded here at #180; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #186 to #189 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (3)
- San Marino First recorded here at #3; earlier position unavailable
- Liechtenstein First recorded here at #4; earlier position unavailable
- Brunei First recorded here at #11; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #169 to #186 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (17)
- Lithuania First recorded here at #46; earlier position unavailable
- Montenegro First recorded here at #47; earlier position unavailable
- South Korea First recorded here at #48; earlier position unavailable
- Latvia First recorded here at #54; earlier position unavailable
- Barbados First recorded here at #57; earlier position unavailable
- Slovenia First recorded here at #68; earlier position unavailable
- Serbia First recorded here at #73; earlier position unavailable
- Armenia First recorded here at #86; earlier position unavailable
- North Macedonia First recorded here at #90; earlier position unavailable
- Kyrgyzstan First recorded here at #128; earlier position unavailable
- Cambodia First recorded here at #141; earlier position unavailable
- Aruba First recorded here at #145; earlier position unavailable
- Togo First recorded here at #156; earlier position unavailable
- Kosovo First recorded here at #173; earlier position unavailable
- Burundi First recorded here at #178; earlier position unavailable
- The Bahamas First recorded here at #183; earlier position unavailable
- Jamaica First recorded here at #184; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved down from #148 to #169 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Positions first recorded above (not confirmed rank jumps) (21)
- Mauritius First recorded here at #63; earlier position unavailable
- Bhutan First recorded here at #67; earlier position unavailable
- Guyana First recorded here at #71; earlier position unavailable
- Japan First recorded here at #77; earlier position unavailable
- Fiji First recorded here at #79; earlier position unavailable
- Belize First recorded here at #83; earlier position unavailable
- Suriname First recorded here at #85; earlier position unavailable
- Moldova First recorded here at #90; earlier position unavailable
- Rwanda First recorded here at #97; earlier position unavailable
- Georgia First recorded here at #105; earlier position unavailable
- Botswana First recorded here at #106; earlier position unavailable
- Mongolia First recorded here at #116; earlier position unavailable
- Namibia First recorded here at #117; earlier position unavailable
- Senegal First recorded here at #127; earlier position unavailable
- Laos First recorded here at #128; earlier position unavailable
- Eswatini First recorded here at #134; earlier position unavailable
- Benin First recorded here at #137; earlier position unavailable
- China First recorded here at #143; earlier position unavailable
- Mauritania First recorded here at #150; earlier position unavailable
- Sierra Leone First recorded here at #166; earlier position unavailable
- Liberia First recorded here at #168; earlier position unavailable
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #149 to #148 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Senegal #113 → #229
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #150 to #149 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Lithuania #49 → #213
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #151 to #150 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Guyana #72 → #204
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #152 to #151 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Cambodia #119 → #194
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #153 to #152 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Armenia #79 → #186
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #156 to #153 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (3)
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #154 to #153 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Georgia #95 → #203
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #155 to #154 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Slovenia #64 → #232
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #156 to #155 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Latvia #52 → #212
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #158 to #156 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
- Guinea-Bissau #157 → #206; points -72.72 → -72.72
- Serbia #52 → #231
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #157 to #156 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Guinea-Bissau #156 → #206
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #158 to #157 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Serbia #52 → #231
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #159 to #158 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Belize #84 → #194
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #159 to #158 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Belize #84 → #194
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #160 to #159 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Bhutan #70 → #197; points -59.75 → -59.75
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #161 to #160 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Aruba #130 → #195
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #162 to #161 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Andorra #9 → #196; points -49.97 → -49.97
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #163 to #161 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (2)
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #163 to #162 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Liberia #160 → #214
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
TBF Abundance rank moved up from #164 to #163 as the published ranking changed. The country-data update clock did not move unless its own dataset also changed.
Rank moved while this country’s points stayed unchanged.
Countries that fell below this country (1)
- Eswatini #133 → #205; points -67.32 → -67.32
Countries previously above that are no longer ranked (2)
- Kazakhstan Previously #120; no longer ranked in this snapshot
- Algeria Previously #125; no longer ranked in this snapshot
and then